Content Section

Best Question From CNN Debate: Why Not Declare War on Iran?

Ron Paul’s debate question was a good one for his GOP rivals and the Tea Party, who constantly accuse Obama of violating the Constitution yet demand that he attack Iran without a declaration of war—as the Constitution requires.

The best question at last night’s CNN debate in Arizona was not asked by the network’s John King. It was asked by Ron Paul to his fellow candidates: If you’re so open to attacking Iran, why not declare war?

GOP Debate

Ron Paul at the debate Wednesday in Mesa, Ariz. (Jae C. Hong / AP Photo)

Think about it. The Republican candidates keep warning that Obama is seizing power at the expense of the Constitution and the people. Yet they’re absolutely fine with him attacking Iran without a congressional declaration of war as required by Article I of the Constitution. They don’t trust Obama to regulate health-insurance companies, but they want to give him sole authority to bomb a country half a world away.

A debate over declaring war on Iran would, to be sure, deny America the element of surprise. But months of Israeli government leaks and GOP debates accomplished that long ago. Declaring war on Iran also would make it easier to justify America’s efforts to cripple Iran’s economy and our complicity in the assassination of its scientists.

They don’t trust Obama to regulate health-insurance companies, but they want to give him sole authority to bomb a country half a world away.

Most important, a congressional debate on declaring war actually would force members of Congress to take a clear position. Today Republicans say that when it comes to Iran, the U.S. should support whatever Israel thinks is best. But it’s pretty clear that what this Israeli government thinks is best is for the United States to bomb. Republicans also say that if there is no other way to prevent an Iranian bomb, America should use force. If they really believe that, why not put it to a vote?

Right now the polling shows: 1. That most Americans support a strike on Iran (presumably to prevent it from getting a nuclear weapon) and 2. That most Americans think Iran already has a nuclear weapon. Which is to say, most Americans don’t know what they’re talking about. A congressional debate might help people pay closer attention and, perhaps, think a little harder about the potential consequences of a third American war in the Muslim world.

How could any self-respecting, Constitution-abiding Tea Partier disagree?

You Might Also Like

Comments

How Mitt Romney's Wacky Family Helps Him Politically

Mitt Romney may have a few Bill Carters in his family, says Newsweek and Daily Beast columnist Michelle Cottle. But that may give Romney the one thing he's hard time finding in this campaign: something in his life story regular people can relate to.

  1. Romney Hits Obama on Solyndra Play

    Romney Hits Obama on Solyndra

  2. President Obama Remembers the Troops Play

    President Obama Remembers the Troops

  3. Biden Speaks at West Point Graduation Play

    Biden Speaks at West Point Graduation

Fringe

With Friends Like These...

7 Secrets of Obama’s Drone War

7 Secrets of Obama’s Drone War

Speed Read Newsweek and The Daily Beast reporter Daniel Klaidman’s dissection of Obama’s war on terror: seven key passages.

Political Legacy

The Next Bhutto—Benazir’s Son

Soda Ban

All Hail the War on Sugar!

Holding Pattern

Get Used to Bad Jobs Data

Presidential Support

Bill Clinton, Two-Edged Sword

 

 

 

NBC News

Courtesy of our partners @ NBC News

Michael Tomasky

The Audacity of Dopes

The Audacity of Dopes

Republicans now suddenly say like parts of the Affordable Care Act. How convenient—and how clueless.

dems-2016-nb01

Let the 2016 Race Begin!

The president has no obvious successor. Let the 2016 jockeying begin.