article

04.06.12

Israel Blames U.S. for Media Reports About Iran Strategy

Insiders are denouncing reports in the U.S. press about military strategy on Iran—and pointing the finger at Washington. Do the disclosures compromise Israel’s security?

Top officials in Israel are charging that national-security leaks coming from the U.S. government are undermining Israel’s military options against Iran. “The problem is the Iranians are certainly paying close attention to these reports,” a senior Israeli official told The Daily Beast. “We are concerned about the leaks and we hope they are not intentional.”

The latest such leak appeared March 28 on Foreign Policy magazine’s website, claiming that Israel had been granted secret access to airbases in Azerbaijan near Iran’s northern border. The piece was sourced to senior U.S. diplomats and military-intelligence officers.

In Washington the article was referred to in a conference call on March 30 between leaders of the American Jewish community and Deputy National Security Adviser Denis McDonough, according to notes of the call provided by a participant in the meeting. The first question McDonough was asked during the meeting was whether the Foreign Policy story was leaked to “undercut Israel.”

McDonough told the Jewish leaders that he personally abhors leaks and that he did not know the sources for the article. He also said he wouldn’t—or couldn’t—confirm the report. “The policy is to press the Iranians, not the Israelis,” McDonough said, according to the notes.

The Foreign Policy piece was written by Mark Perry, a journalist and author who specializes in intelligence and military matters. He has reported a series of exclusives about the U.S.-Israel relationship, including a piece this year that claimed Israeli Mossad officers were posing as CIA officers to recruit Iranian opposition figures for operations in Iran. The Daily Beast was not able to confirm the report.

Leaks from both the Israeli and U.S. defense and intelligence communities have been a treasure trove in the last year for national-security reporters.

Perry has provided counsel to the Palestinian side of the Arab-Israeli conflict. Between 1989 and 2004, he served as an unofficial and unpaid adviser to Yassir Arafat. After that he became the codirector of Conflicts Forum, a nongovernmental organization that specializes in bringing journalists and policymakers into contact with groups throughout the Middle East and South Asia that have been designated by the State Department as foreign terrorist organizations, such as Hezbollah. In 2009 he left that group after his codirector Alastair Crooke, a retired British MI6 officer, wrote an op-ed questioning whether the Iranian regime had really killed Neda, the iconic Iranian woman protester whose death was captured on YouTube.

Perry denied his recent article had an Obama-administration connection. “I’m not on the White House speed dial,” Perry told The Daily Beast. “I have no reason to believe that this story was intentionally planted with me. I followed up an initial report and built up the information over a series of months.”

Leaks from both the Israeli and U.S. defense and intelligence communities have been a treasure trove in the last year for national-security reporters. The Daily Beast, for example, in November reported details of Israel’s electronic war capabilities against Iran.

But the latest report comes after last month’s state visit to Washington by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Both U.S. and Israeli officials have characterized those meetings as successful.  In their wake, Israel has, for example, started sharing more of its military-planning data with the United States. And President Obama pleased Israel by declaring that it is U.S. policy to prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons, not to contain an Iran that has obtained such weapons.

“The administration has been unequivocal about Israel’s right to defend itself and the United States has done more to bolster Israel’s defense through the foreign military financing of $3 billion a year and done more than any country in the world,” a senior administration official said.

At the same time, it’s no secret that Obama and his top advisers are also seeking to dissuade Israel from launching an airstrike on Iranian nuclear facilities. On Monday, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton reiterated this theme. “It’s our very strong belief, as President Obama conveyed to the Israelis, that it is not in anyone’s interest for them to take unilateral action,” Clinton said. “It is in everyone’s interest for us to seriously pursue at this time the diplomatic path.”