Blogs and Stories
Resolved: Sarah Palin Is Not Andrew Jackson
)
Bill Kristol's comparison of the Alaskan governor to Old Hickory doesn't fly.
First, a stipulation: I like and respect Bill Kristol. There is, as you might expect, a “but” coming.
This morning in Maureen Dowd’s column in The New York Times, Bill compared Sarah Palin to Andrew Jackson. I have just finished five years of work on a Jackson biography, and am therefore particularly sensitive on this topic, and I have written about my reservations about Governor Palin in Newsweek. So Bill’s remark resonated with me on several levels.
The chief problem with the Palin-Jackson analogy is that Jackson was, by the time he came to the White House in 1829, a senior figure in American life. He had defeated the British at New Orleans and added millions upon millions of acres of land to the United States through his Indian campaigns. He served as a judge, a senator, a general, and, in 1824, won a plurality of the votes for president, only to lose the election to John Quincy Adams in the House of Representatives. He was much more than a mayor and a governor of two years’ standing.
For Palin admirers, there is much to like in a Jackson analogy. He was largely unlettered, ran as a champion of the people versus elites, and consistently surprised political observers and prognosticators with success upon success. But Jackson was an experienced hand at public affairs, and his populism, while genuinely felt, was not unthinking or unreflective. Perhaps Palin’s vision of the world is more complex than we know. If it is, she has 19 days to prove it.
Bringing Down Bachmann
Benjamin Sarlin is a reporter for The Daily Beast. He previously covered New York City politics for The New York Sun and has worked for talkingpointsmemo.com.
America's Hot Jobs (and Not Jobs)
The Daily Beast is dedicated to news and commentary, culture, and entertainment. We carefully curate the web’s most essential stories and bring you original must-reads from our talented contributors.
Nicolas Cage, Compulsive Spender
Jacob Bernstein is a senior reporter at The Daily Beast. Previously, he was a features writer at WWD and W Magazine. He has also written for New York magazine, Paper, and The Huffington Post.
While not an expert on Jackson, I am a history buff and was quite confused by the Palin-Jackson comparison. Thank you for clearing up my confusion with historical facts. And 19 days or not, I don't think she's got it.
I'll just say this, over the last eight years Bill Kristol has lost most if not all of my respect because of saying things like...oh I don't know...that Sarah Palin is comparable to ANDREW JACKSON.
I liken that, "she has 19 days to prove it." Good to end with a chuckle. Keep it up - love to read you.
"lowly task of stirring up the whack-job fringe of the party's right wing and of recycling patent falsehoods"
Sounds like the political strategy of the last admin.
If the voters don't fall for the provincialisms and symbolic exploitations this time around, at least Sarah has a home to go back to where she can be forgotten.
I am so glad that someone finally gets this: Sarah Palin is a yahoo. Jackson is well known for having been a yahoo ... in fact, I believe he's the President credited with having had his inauguration party ruined b/c his yahoo relatives and guests tore the place to shreds. Yeah that's what I want repping me in the White House ...
And humans are only 4% different genetically than apes. Lots of similarities there. But verrrrry different. Kristol's Palin/Jackson analogy is thusly strained.
Yeah, plus, Andy Jackson couldn't see Russia from his house.
I wonder what "Palinian Democracy" would look like? There would be more snowmobiles and fewer newspapers, fer sure. And Alaska would finally be granted its independence, you betcha.
"Oh, Bill Kristol, are you EVER right?"
Perhaps she is Jackson-Lite??
What a ludicrous comparison.The only similarity is that both came from "white trash" backgrounds. Andy pulled himself out of his. He also had in him none of the intellectual (or other) cowardice Ms. Palin demonstrates daily by refusing to answer questions or even to submit to them. Andy would certainly never have bungled answers to questions, though he may have answered in terms that might have frightened a timid questioner. As his very full life of leadership demonstrated, his character contained infinitely more steel than our current national disgrace, the twinkle-eyed Thrilla From Wasilla.
You lost everyone when you said that you "respect" Bill Kristol, unless, of course ,you were starting off with a joke, in which case: good one.
Thank you for standing up for Old Hickory. Many of us are getting our first look at his presidency through our financial history cramming. To say he is relevant now is an understatement.
Someone needs to send this racist hick back to Alaska so she can be recalled.
I'm no Palin fan, Austerlitz, but "white trash background"? Her mom was a school secretary and her dad taught science and coached track. Sounds pretty solid and decent to me. And Jackson, BTW, was the son of rural Scots-Irish immigrants; again, not what I think of as "white trash."
Wasn't Jackson functionally illierate? Is that not an apt comparison? I wonder how many duels Palin has been in.
As a member of a Cherokee tribe, I am sad to see so many people who seem to have forgotten the bad things that Andrew Jackson did as well. For the writer to be such a history buff and highly published historian, he failed to mention the one particularly appalling and heinous act of Andrew Jackson. After using the Cherokee as allies to win the Battle of Horseshoe Bend against the Creeks, he introduced the Indian Removal Act. This act allowed the removal and relocation of the "savages" (so savage that 90% of the Cherokee nation could read and write at this time). The US Supreme Court declared this to be unconstitutional, illegal, and against treaties already in effect. However, Jackson instituted it anyway. The reason I provide all this historical background is that I feel that Sarah Palin would definitely be capable of this very act, feeling smug and superior the whole time. We should all be afraid of letting another condescending and completely undeserving person like George W. in the White House again...look at where it has gotten us.
Thank you.
As a first time user, your comment has been submitted for review. It can take anywhere from a few hours to a day or two for your comment to be reviewed, depending on the time of week and the volume of comments we receive.
Please log in to leave comments.