Blogs and Stories
What Sarah Palin Didn't Say
There was one subject we didn't hear enough about in Part One of the Alaskan governor’s media blitz.
So far the interviews with Sarah Palin in her TV media blitz have failed to answer the only question I’m interested in: Now that it’s all over, Sarah, who does look after the kids?
I could never see a shot of the dynamite-looking Palin sashaying out to greet the crowd in those borrowed gladrags without thinking of what it must be like backstage. If it was anything like the early childrearing scene in my own house, the baby was throwing up, Piper was bleating about her missing coloring book, Bristol was sitting sullenly with her iPod giving every one filthy looks, and Todd Palin didn’t notice any of it because he was on the phone.
Frockgate—the revelation that the GOP spent $150,000 on the former hockey mom’s designer duds—only heightened the collective female desire to hear Palin tell it like it really was on the campaign trail, standing there in her pantyhose in the hotel suite, stabbing at her BlackBerry while also struggling into a too-small Galliano jacket that looked great on the hanger but has some fantail flourish at the back that makes her butt look big. “Can someone undo this darn zip! Shoot! Now my hair’s messed up!” Come on, Sarah, fess up! We know it happened!
It was the most ferocious TV assault on a chopping board since Martha Stewart went at it with a defenseless vegetable on the Early Show shortly after she was indicted on charges of conspiracy, obstruction of justice and securities fraud.
I have always suspected that Hillary Clinton wept when she was taking questions from a small group of women at Cafe Expresso in Portsmouth, just before the New Hampshire primary, because of the subtext of the question she was asked: “How do you stay so upbeat and so wonderful?” Surely it was the mere thought of those predawn blow-dry sessions (while Barack Obama got his extra half-hour in bed) that made the steel-nerved junior senator from New York tear up for the first time and reveal the bone-tired effort of it all. Women across the state knew all about that daily effort to look good when you feel like shit. They emotionally identified with Hillary Clinton as they had failed to do in the months before. And they voted for her.
Both Matt Lauer and Greta Van Susteren filmed the Palins preparing a dinner of moose chili in the family kitchen at home in Wasilla. Van Susteren told me that it was clear from her two-day visit that the Palins are a typical American family in which “everyone pitches in” with the kids. The grandparents do their bit, Todd does his bit, Bristol is there to babysit. Palin told Van Susteren, “I have it a heck of a lot easier, though, than most any other woman that I know, though, because of Todd and his—the comfort level that he has in doing a whole lot of the domestic stuff and the kids' stuff and the flexibility that he has. Though he has a very busy work schedule, it's flexible enough where when he is home, he takes over a lot of the house duties and the kids' duties.”
But as every woman knows, assurances like that are only half true. It’s sure to be the governor herself who has to keep the family show on the road. You could tell that from the way she sliced that reindeer sausage. It was the most ferocious TV assault on a chopping board since Martha Stewart went at it with a defenseless vegetable on the Early Show shortly after she was indicted on charges of conspiracy, obstruction of justice and securities fraud.
That’s why the missed opportunity in Palin’s interviews (interviews that will be rich ridicule fodder for other reasons) was her answer to Van Susteren’s most sisterly question about the ordeals of the campaign: “Was it harder on your family, do you think?” “My family's pretty tough,” she replied, “and they—because I've been in local office and state office since '92. You know, the kids have grown up with this. I think they're kind of used to that, which is sort of unfortunate, if you think about it, that they've—you know, they've grown up seeing things said and written about their mom that, you know, even they know hasn't always been true. But I think that they know that that's sort of the nature of the beast of politics.”
Oh, really? Eight-month-old Trig knows? Seven-year-old Piper, who was yanked from school and her friends for two months, knows? I’m unwilling to believe that Palin is an uncaring mother, so this blithe statement of unreflective parenting reflects and reinforces what working women with children seem obliged to tell themselves.
Politically and policy-wise, Palin’s post-election publicity blitz, like her two-month run as McCain’s running mate, demonstrated that she was at least four years, and more likely eight, from being ready for national prime time. But she could play a valuable leadership role—right now—by being honest about and sharing what she really does know about: combining healthy ambition with mothering five kids. Confronting the pain she must have felt—and, even I dare to suggest, the guilt she won’t allow is there—at her own parental oversight when her teenage daughter got pregnant. Struggling with that other decision she has also blown off as an easy call: to continue with her own late-in-life pregnancy when she found she would give birth to a Down syndrome baby. (And it was a decision, “pro-life” platitudes notwithstanding.) If Sarah Palin would address these things honestly with American women and tell it like it really is, she might not redeem the intellectual blunders of the trail. But she might redeem herself, and—who knows?—maybe, someday, win herself national office.
Tina Brown is the Founder and Editor in Chief of The Daily Beast. She is the author of the 2007 New York Times best seller The Diana Chronicles.
Note: This article has been corrected to note that Martha Stewart appeared on the Early Show, not the Today Show as originally published.
The Right Dumps Carrie
Jacob Bernstein is a senior reporter at The Daily Beast. Previously, he was a features writer at WWD and W Magazine. He has also written for New York magazine, Paper, and The Huffington Post.
What's Joe's Problem?
Lloyd Grove is editor at large for The Daily Beast. He is also a frequent contributor to New York magazine and was a contributing editor for Condé Nast Portfolio. He wrote a gossip column for the New York Daily News from 2003 to 2006. Prior to that, he wrote the Reliable Source column for the Washington Post, where he spent 23 years covering politics, the media, and other subjects.
Geithner's Stock Plummeting
Jeff Madrick is a contributor to the New York Review of Books and a former economics columnist for the New York Times. He is editor of Challenge Magazine, visiting professor of humanities at Cooper Union, and senior fellow at the New School's Schwartz Center for Economic Policy Analysis. He is the author of Taking America, The End of Affluence (Random House) and The Case for Big Government.
Sarah Drops the Act
Tina Brown is the founder and editor-in-chief of The Daily Beast. She is the author of the 2007 New York Times best seller The Diana Chronicles. Brown is the former editor of Tatler, Vanity Fair, The New Yorker, and Talk magazines and host of CNBC's Topic A with Tina Brown.
Sarah Palin, the Musical
Tina Brown is the founder and editor-in-chief of The Daily Beast. She is the author of the 2007 New York Times best seller The Diana Chronicles. Brown is the former editor of Tatler, Vanity Fair, The New Yorker, and Talk magazines and host of CNBC's Topic A with Tina Brown.
Hillary Finally Doffs Her Burqa
Tina Brown is the founder and editor-in-chief of The Daily Beast. She is the author of the 2007 New York Times best seller The Diana Chronicles. Brown is the former editor of Tatler, Vanity Fair, The New Yorker, and Talk magazines and host of CNBC's Topic A with Tina Brown.
Frockgate? Seriously, Tina, Frockgate? You've been living in the States for how long now?
As to the actual point of the piece (such as it is) I really can't imagine that the American voter is going to care much about Governor Palin's childrearing skills when they go to cast their votes in four, or however many years. And, I, for one, have absolutely no interest in hearing about how she felt when she learned the news about Bristol's pregnancy. Frankly, that's her businesss. What would interest me is a bit more information about why the Governor tried to fire the Wasilla librarian. I'd like to hear more about her views on criminalizing abortion, drilling in the ANWR, evolution, abstinence-only sex education in schools, and climate change, including whether or not she believes that polar bears are an endangered species. I'm tempted to add witchcraft to the list, but I'll let that one go for now.
But no, when it comes to choosing the next leader of the free world, how Sarah Palin manages to balance her family and career are not a top priority.
Correction -- make that:
"how Sarah Palin manages to balance her family and career IS not a top priorty."
And it isn't.
This user is no longer registered.
Tina, et al; throughout Palin's campaign my inner child has cringed repeatedly:
her special needs infant was without shoes or socks in october at her debate; she carries him with no head support--like a sack of something; her small 7-yr-old child often babysits, and was filmed carrying the infant around the house and up the stairs by herself while their parents were getting interviewed.
being the oldest of 8, i can tell you right now who takes care of those kids, and it ain't the parents.
Comments are ridiculous. I agree with the articule. Working women, with kids are interested in this topic, and it IS a top priority. Did you not read or hear that it's a top priority for Mrs. Obama to work on issues related to working mothers?! Carter - you may want to read and be up on more of the news. your out of date... say 50 years...
Oh Tina, I fear you took the cancellation of Topic A With Tina Brown a little too much to heart. America is ready for a show of that caliber now! I just don't see the depth and topics of interest in your writing here that you brought to that show, and I am struggling to recognise you lately... but I am glad you are back.
I am sure Governor Palin would make a lovely friend or talkshow host, but other than that she is a political footnote, and I really wish you would stop trying to make any more of it and concentrate your journalistic talents on topics more deserving
You want to know how a country run by her would be like? Look at her house (family). Total disarray and disfunction. No thank you. More than anything, I hate people who are hypocrites. Especially RWingers who fail to practice what they preach. Her religion is one of intolerance. Therefore, she will not be tolerated by me. Stay in Alaska, Sarah. We don't want you. (just the very ignorant and racists ones do; oh, and let's not forget the joe-six-packs who have a big hard on for you. Geeze, in 8 years, you will be 52 years old. It all goes down hill from here, inlcuding your looks and your body. Too bad.
Palin's juggling of obligations doesn't strike me as special. She should be asking more experienced, less ignorant 'hockey moms' about how to do this. She exposed her pregnant, unmarried daughter to this press blitz by accepting the nomination. That doesn't strike as putting parenting at the top of the priority list.
I understand that with her busy schedule she might not have time to read things that affect national policy, but she had a choice: she could have stayed in Alaska and learned to juggle her family and that office before reaching higher.
Her hypocritical supporters would never have allowed Obama onto the national stage with a pregnant daughter. She shouldn't be allowed there either--not because she's a career mom, but because she's profoundly unready.
Tina -- did you notice the moment where Matt Lauer was asking Piper how she felt about the campaign trail and Piper was making noises about it not being that great? Matt Lauer followed up and asked Piper if she would want to do it again and she didn't seem too enthused. In what I can only describe as pure Mommie Dearest, Palin asked Piper again, and it was obvious from the expression on Palin's face, and the tone of her voice, that the correct answer to the question about doing it again was "yes" -- which Piper dutifully delivered. It turned my stomach, and tells me all I need to know about who Palin really is.
Tina - this is absurd. This is a woman consumed with blind ambition, incuriousness about the world she sought to govern, and an anti-intellectual redneck attitude. Comparing Hilary Clinton to this trailer trash is absurd on so many levels. Her parenting is the least of it - but certainly her stance on Sex education and her own daughter's pregnancy made it fair game. End the apologia and let her fade into the dustbin of history where she belongs...would never have expected this kind of thing from you of all people...
I think frockgate is a fine term carter.
And Ms Brown, I have thought from the begining that Sarah Palin should have talked about the decision to keep the baby. The very hard core pro lifers were thrilled with her declarations about always keeping the baby, but I think the rest of the country (pro-life, pro-choice, whatever) thought it sounded dishonest. I'm certain that any woman whos ever had kids, thought about kids, worried about unplanned pregnancy - whatever - knows this would be a tough choice. And then finding out that she hid the pregnancy for 7 months makes it pretty obvious that she wasn't sure -- or why hide it? And people (especially those WOMEN VOTERS aka Hillary-supporters that McCain wanted to steal) would have been moved and touched by her account of her struggle between a difficult choice (a down syndrome baby) and doing what she considered the "Right thing" -- keeping the baby. Americans LOVE that story, they love it. Even if they aren't personally committed to that "right thing" they love hearing about people making difficult "do the right thing" decisions. Instead she came off as preachy, thoughtless, and disturbingly out of touch with how a real person would have dealt with that situation.
If the Palins felt so strongly about right-to-life, why do you suppose they submitted to the test for Down's-- doesn't that indicate considering termination ?
I hadn't even thought of this. Very apt observation.
Who are Palin's other two kids?
Tina, would it be impossible for you to refer to a baby with Down syndrome, rather than a Downs syndrome baby?
Golly, Thalyssa, maybe Troopergate would have had more legs if it had been called Bobbiegate instead. Catchy, that!
Meanwhile, the world waits for to share her innermost feelings and cooking tips, I'll be wondering how to pay the mortgage on my flat.
People who are anti- abortion rarely, if ever,
have pre-natal testing.
Someone should ask Palin what her purpose was in getting pre-natal testing on this last baby.
It makes no sense unless she was thinking of the possibility of abortion.
Think about it.
She's just not a reliable authority on anything. Including herself, witness the weasel/waffling on the clothing issue.
Dishonest.
I don't agree with Sarah Palin's political views, but do we ask the male candidates' children about how they feel about their daddy running for office? When a woman makes the choice to run for public office, they should be judged in the same way as their male opponents. Palin will have the opportunity to learn more about issues outside of Alaska during the next few years and appears smart enough to be able to be a viable candidate in the future.
the beast...still, the bloody beast must be fed...? man-oh-man, Tina.
Not sure why my comment didn't post earlier, but...
Ever since Palin came on the scene, my inner child has cringed. No one spoke of how her special needs infant was being bandied about in the loudest of atmospheres; how he wasn't wearing any shoes or even socks during her VP debate--held in October; or how she carries him--with no support for his head, like a drooping bag of something.
A recent interview of Todd & Sarah in their home documented how their little girl, all of 7 years old, carries the baby around the house and up the steps, by herself, without a thought or glance from the pair being interviewed.
Having observed their dynamics, and being the oldest in a large and only semi-functional family, I can assure you that the main one taking care of their children are the children.
How about how little this family values education? Her husband is a high school dropout; so is her oldest son, her oldest daughter, the daughter's fiance, and she pulled her two other kids, Willow and Piper, out of school for over two months. She herself barely got a college degree from schools that are barely community college level.
So it was no surprise to me that she didn't realize that Africa is a continent or that she couldn't name the countries in North America. That she was more interested in shopping for clothes than learning about foreign policy. I'm sure her go-to answer is, God will provide. Let her continue her war against learning and books. Let her start her own written word bonfire and rail against the media or be unable to list *any* newspapers or periodicals that she actually reads. This is the person halfwit Billy Kristol wanted to foist upon us.
Palin would be more appropriate on Flavor of Love than in national politics, but as long as she stays in Alaska, she can spout crazy all she wants.
I truly believe that she is bi-polar...please Dr's...what do you think?
Pressured speech: The person speaks very fast, as if his or her mouth can't keep up with the rapid thoughts. The person may be unable to respond to social cues to stop talking.
Narcissim: A pattern of traits and behaviors which signify infatuation and obsession with one's self to the exclusion of all others and the egotistic and ruthless pursuit of one's gratification, dominance and ambition.
Self-esteem may be inflated.
Decisions regarding business and finances are often made hurriedly and without careful consideration; poor choices may be the result.
Clothing choices may also change, and the person in a manic phase may start wearing brighter, more flamboyant clothes.
They are grandiose and may have delusions (false ideas) of grandeur (greatness)
Delusions (false beliefs)
In the manic phase of bipolar disorder, feelings of heightened energy, creativity, and euphoria are common. People experiencing a manic episode often talk a mile a minute, sleep very little, and are hyperactive. They may also feel like they're all-powerful, invincible, or destined for greatness.
Racing thoughts; jumping quickly from one idea to the next
Highly distractible, unable to concentrate
Impaired judgment and impulsiveness
Acting recklessly without thinking about the consequences
I wonder what the reaction by many of us would've been if Michelle Obama walked on stage with five children including a pregnant teenage daughter?
Definitely would not have remained a "private family matter."
Just as the majority of women on assistance and Food Stamps
remains a "private matter" while women of color ( the minority)
in the same straits are the most discussed ( and condemned) social concern among so many groups.
Wow, Pupster, you've managed to included nearly every single debunked smear against Palin in three short paragraphs. Now that's some talent.
Hey Carter, I want to know because she doesn't have a handle what makes you think she can handle the country? Sorry I think she and her husband are not great role models for parents. Also the way they would hold that baby like a sack of potatoes. You would have thought all that money they spent on cloths they could have bought a baby stroller.
Thank you.
As a first time user, your comment has been submitted for review. It can take anywhere from a few hours to a day or two for your comment to be reviewed, depending on the time of week and the volume of comments we receive.
Please log in to leave comments.