Blogs and Stories
Irrational Obama Exuberance
No President of Black America: The election of Obama as an evolutionary step past America's original sin of slavery cannot be overstated. But the most beautiful thing about it was the way went largely un-remarked by the candidate or his campaign.
It was, in this respect, a quiet American revolution: Obama presented himself as an American individual first, not, as Teddy Roosevelt would say, "a hyphenated American." And he was rewarded by the American people in part for this transcendence of the racial politics of our recent past.
A feature of our political life for the past three-decades has been the African American protest presidential candidacy—first and semi-credibly Jesse Jackson, and then far less so, Al Sharpton. (We'll leave Shirley Chisholm, Alan Keyes and Carol Moseley-Braun out of this). The point of these campaigns was less to win the presidency than to own a title that has been up for grabs since the assassination of Dr. King—the president of black America. That post will now be vacated forever, not because we've reached the end of racism in our nation, but because we have a black president of all America.
The Low Road didn't lead to the White House: In his stump speeches before Iowa, Obama promised to lead a "party that doesn't just focus on how to win but why we should." He was campaigning against the hyper-partisan politics of personal destruction that has dominated Washington for too long. What's more remarkable and gratifying is that he kept his word.
Cynical political consultants love to point out that while Americans always say they want less negative campaigning, it works. The end, in their eyes, justifies the means. That's how hardball is played. And even honorable politicians can fall into this trap—when George H. W. Bush listened to Lee Atwater, the Willie Horton ad was deployed. The message: You have to be willing to campaign dirty in order to have the opportunity to govern clean.
But Obama kept his own counsel and elevated the game. Faced with a bewildering array of low-blow attacks, first from the Hillary Clinton campaign and then McCain-Palin, Obama kept his cool. He was called a socialist who palled around with terrorists; hysterical whisper campaigns alleged that he was a Muslim Marxist Manchurian candidate, even the anti-Christ, while official opposition ads at times were almost uniformly negative.
Faced with outright fear-mongering, Obama did not respond in kind. He realized that taking the bait would create a moral equivalence while allowing opponents to play the victim card. Instead, in a bit of political judo, he made the attacks the issue, a desperate sign of the politics of the past. He was called weak by some for not firing back, but he understood that we actually do want honor restored to our politics. Obama gambled on the common sense and the common decency of the American people, and he won.
So there are reasons for the afterglow after this historic election. Enjoy it. The Washington sausage-making process will commence soon enough. But by appealing to the better angels of our nature, as opposed to betting on the success of partisan politics as usual, President-elect Obama has uplifted our national image and updated the American Dream. That's what we call a new birth of freedom. And that's reason to give thanks.
John P. Avlon is the author of Independent Nation: How Centrists Can Change American Politics. Avlon also served as Director of Speechwriting and Deputy Director of Policy for Rudy Giuliani's Presidential Campaign. Previously, he was a columnist for the New York Sun and served as Chief Speechwriter and Deputy Communications Director for Mayor Rudolph Giuliani. He worked on Bill Clinton's 1996 presidential campaign.









To coin a phrase using a silent H. "It's BHO time."
Yes. There is such good cheer all round our "tired electorate" which is happy to be distracted by anything. And certainly Obama pleases by being so Christmas-esque. Feel good stuff all built on a fantasy and marketed well - and forever - by a commercially driven media and the money powers that be.
Enjoy the Happy Holidays while you can! The hang-over cometh.
BTW. A whole bunch of people out here are not impressed with Obama and his cabinet picks. Analyzed closely, they tell the tale of the same inexperienced, slippery politician from the Chicago machine who can't make a hard decision of his own to save his life. Everything he has done so far is straddling the fence, kicking the can down the road and adopting other mechanisms designed to cover his own lack of decisive backbone and administrative skill.
He defeats Hillary by ridiculing her for a lack of foreign policy experience - then makes her Secretary of State? He defeats the Bush GOP by railing against the Iraqi war - and then keeps Bush's top war gun GATES AND GATE'S HENCHMEN on to run the OBAMA WARS?
And that's a good thing? Perhaps a little EGGNOG for the left would be a better choice this holiday season THAN KOOL AID!
Exuberance is the word of the day, the month, the year. This is helping the building of a New Administration. And the President -Elect is taking advantage of the Exuberance. Experts from California, Chicago, New York, Washington DC, People with real experience in 5 or six different administrations. Women, Blacks, Hispanics, and veterans. And the manner in which Obama is publishing these appointments, keeps the energy growing. Some say artificial time limits mean nothing. But, I think the first 100 days following January 20th must produce, and produce a lot.
A political electorate which demands miracles of its candidates, both sides of the fence please, is one of the reason all politicians are considered slippery or failures. We routinely disparaged and demean our elected leaders, failing to note WE elected them. The electorate should realize, we elect them to represent and fight for our interests, but being a democracy, not necessarily win every fight. There will be concession and compromise. We have to realize our politicians are human and honor them for trying to lead us to our better selves.
Bliss and afterglow... I feel I'm in Poland and Karol Wojtyla just got elected Pope...
Obama was the anti-war candidate. Short of Hartford, Connecticut being over-run by foreign troops, there is no need to bomb anyone anywhere. No bombing would be awesome.
I find this adulation nauseating. Perhaps we could hold off on it for a while until Obama actually accomplishes something.
Is that asking too much?
I find this criticism nauseating. Perhaps we could hold off on it for a while until Obama actually screws something up.
Is that asking too much?
I voted for Obama feeling he'd wind up being a centrist and not a left leaning marxist loon as portrayed by conservative gas bags. On the other hand all the pom-pom waving, genuflecting for Obama from the NBC family of "journalists" was sickening. Let's keep it real. Many of the airhead "like-you-know" mall walkers supported Obama for cult of personality ... the MTV Vote ... the "Coolness" factor, and probably never heard of Condoleezza Rice, and could probably be convinced she's some kind of side dish.
"of what we've come accostomed to ..." ?????????? I guess you could use a few more editors, as well as all those sorely lacking proofreaders.
And to nauseated tomfarr -- it's not adulation of Obama you're unhappy with; you were obviously opposed to him as a candidate and disapproving of everything he did 'back then.' Nothing he does in the future will please you, no doubt. It's not Obama that causes those queasy feelings, I'm sure; it's the change he will bring (and has already brought) that makes your blood run cold.
Obama may turn out to be a very good president. It's hard to know in advance, since he has never held an executive position.
I wish him well, since he'll be running the country, along with the crassest of political hacks Pelosi and Reid. Most of his appointments up to now are pretty good. But appointments are not a record of achievement. Everything remains to be seen.
For now, hosannahs and hallelujahs are premature.
Mr. Avlon--hire a copy editor.
LindaA1 - you seem to be suffering from a bad case of sour grapes - maybe some Pepto might help with that bad taste in your mouth. Unfortunately, it won't help you open your mind enough to consider that an intelligent leader might not look or act like the selfish dolts who have brought our country to these dire straights with their slick mis-management and self-serving ways. I'm not surprised so many people like yourself are not capable of recognizing what good leadership looks like, there has been so little of it in the past 8 years.
For those that haven't seen reasons for jublilation I'd like to clarify at least two things that have changed because of BHO's election. 1) elections in America have been given back to the people that vote. Up to now, unless you had lobbyists, big business and very rich people on your side you couldn't run for nomination, let alone president. BHO has demonstrated that if you have the right message you can go to the people for your support and they will provide it. and 2) a black man was elected president in America. This illustrates, due to his courage in attempting to be elected, that we as a people (at least those who vote) have made significant progress in ignoring race as a significant factor in deciding who should run the country. These two sea changes will remake US history more than anything he can do in office and if he died tomorrow (god(s) forbid) his impact will be none-the-less.
Finally, I would like to say that anything BHO does will be better that we have seen from the last 8 years of WHB reign of terror, so rejoice there is a new "decision maker" in town.
You have to laugh when people blithely describe Pelosi and Reid as the crassest of political hacks when we've had to contend with Gingrich, DeLay, Boehner, Bush et al. What Benchmark do these people use. Actually Reid, while not JFK, is a fairly good example of immense personal achievement in the American tradition while Pelosi is a third generation politico of centrist persuasion and the first woman to make it to speaker which suggests some talent for her job. Most of the people who make these kind of hyperbolic comments would have trouble running a pretzel stand but it's a free country I suppose which entitles them to make these juvenile comments. On the subject of Obama, he is of course demonstrating just how good he is and it's getting right up the nose of the far right. Basically he's completely outflanked them with his appointments which have collected universal applause from Dems, independants and moderate Republicans. There are inevitably going to be misteps but nothing serious while he implements a dramatic policy of change that will be wormwood and ashes to the right, executed by competent pragmatists of the center left and center right, thus satisfying Disraeli's definition of the most effective form of govt: Tory men and liberal measures.
Merit? Is this a joke? What has Obama done to show he has any merit whatsoever? Giving a good speech is not even remotely close to being a good president. You can hate on Bush all you want, but as a two-time successful governor of Texas, he had demonstrated far more merit than Obama.
The exurberance, it will turn out quite destructive. Th leftwing bubble which Obama has produced will pop like all others, only this time the ramification will stretch across all aspects of the economy. You simply can't do the things he is proposing to do and expect it to turn out good. Our only hope, and one which is looking at least possible, is that he may just be a great liar, and has no intention of implementing much of what he promised. Not that yet another dishonest president is something to celebrate.
"He kept his word"? He broke a promise to accept public financing when he figured out he could make millions more privately and has destroyed campaign finance reform forever. Money talks and he is its poster boy.
He took the high road? He defended a racist preacher until the preacher told the rest of us what Obama has been listening to for 20 years of Sundays.
He "faced a bewildering array of low-blow attacks" ? What - socialist and Muslim? Sarah Palin has been called unprintable names starting with every letter of the alphabet, and Obama has never disapproved.
He wanted to get elected and he did whatever it took to do so. He is no different from any other politician. The sooner this messiah-worship is over, the sooner we can find out if his character matches his rhetoric. The jury is still out on that.
To claim that Obama wasn't negative is pure revisionism. He falsely attacked McCain on a number of fronts. McCain was computer illiterate. Or he wanted to take your social security (a perennial leftwing lie). "Erratic" was also a consistent attack from the Obama talking points.
But please, tell us how awesomely "above it all" The One was. It's obvious you've drunk too much kool-aid to be taken seriously, anyway.
Knowing that, according to the record available, BO, having secured office by eliminating his opponents, did little of value once in office to help the poorer constituents in the districts he represented in IL, instead aiding and abetting his hoodlum anti-Semitic buddies by redistributing state, federal, and private charitable funds to them; and that, reneging on his promise to participate in public campaign financing during the Presidential campaign, he was able to vacuum in millions of illegal dollars into his personal glad bag from foreign sources in part by manipulating fund raising software intended to curb such abuses; on what basis are people now so optimistic that if he becomes President Obama, this leopard will change his spots? Oh, that's right; they haven't examined his record.
God forbid we elect a president we are actually enthusiastic about. I had no idea this had become a political crime in America. Obama's detractors need to be mindful of the fact that the American popular vote was won by a Democrat in 4 out of the last 5 elections, yet that majority still had to endure Bush politics for the last 8 years of our lives. If you're tired of hearing people disagree with you express happiness over our political situation, I suggest you get used to it.
clubed60090 -
I always know when I'm ahead of a commenter when they start with a tired old insult like "sour grapes."
As for your analysis about leadership and my not knowing a good leader when I see one, let me remind you that a good leader is one who leads well. That's when I pick my good leaders - AFTER they have proven that they lead well.
You, on the other hand, apparently pick your "good leaders" before they lead well - based on media hype and your own personal fantasies.
Obama will fail--not because he isn't cool, but because the days of liberal soak the rich policies are over. Liberalism is failing all over the world. Nobody left to overtax. His cabinet members are old line hacks who failed in the BJ Clinton administration.
The question is when will it all collapse -- welfare days on the wane.
The election was many things, but a "silent" revolution was not one of them. I believe there was an overwhelming sense of pride and commitment to our new president-elect Barack Obama. I also believe you are right that the smear mongers will start up soon enough. So let's enjoy and celebrate the happy times while we can. Visit "Gettin' Ready" on YouTube.
When you hear it, you'll be tapping your feet!
You'll be back in a happy-era.
You'll be singing along.
You'll be part of...the dream.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tia253AMjHA
"We elected not just the first black man".
Please the election is over! Obama mother was white and he is no more black than white.
"Obama presented himself as an American individual first" -
See the above as to why he couldn't claim to be 'black'.
Almost all sites and journalists have given up on the 'black' bit for obvious reasons so maybe the "Beast" should too?!
Mike
How many butt worshiping editorials will I have to read about the left's messiah? Sorry to inform the media about their creation, but he only got 53% of the vote. Yeah, he won, but it's asking too darn much for the country to buy this over-the-top worship of this guy. I think he'll be a big failure. He's so overblown! Frankly, I hope he fails. It will teach our country not to buy a load of dog crap so easily from the media.
You're right, bgarst, about the negative campaign against McCain. Yet, it is not false to label McCain computer illiterate; he actually is. The point is that it is not relevant to leadership. To describe McCain as erratic is a fair assessment; even Karl Rove described him as such after the election. Negative campaigning based on fact and perception is not necessarily false. As for Obama being perceived to be above it all, it worked and still works. Machiavelli recommended it. Greatness in leaders demands it. Obama is aiming for the same Teflon quality that Ronald Reagan had. Were you drinking Reagan's Kool-Aid in the 80's? Different flavor but still Kool-Aid.
Thank you.
As a first time user, your comment has been submitted for review. It can take anywhere from a few hours to a day or two for your comment to be reviewed, depending on the time of week and the volume of comments we receive.
Please log in to leave comments.