Blogs and Stories
Arab Blogosphere Erupts Over Shoegate
Karim Kadim/AP
In the Arab world, the shoe-throwing incident prompts a mix of outrage, applause, and bad jokes. Plus: Translating the best cartoons.
Arab reaction to the shoe-throwing incident at President Bush’s Baghdad press conference on Sunday was a mixed bag. While some hailed reporter Muntather al-Zaidi as a hero for hurling his shoes at the US president, others thought the attack was a disgrace to Iraq and to the journalistic profession.
Iraqi blogger Nibras Kazimi, who was clearly outraged, wrote that he would “seriously consider beating the crap” out of Zaidi, and added that he’d like to “take one of his [Zaidi’s] shoes…and stuff it in his mouth.” The Iraqi government issued a sharp condemnation of the reporter’s “barbaric and shameful behavior.”
By contrast, Abdul-Bari Atwan, the Palestinian editor of the London-based daily al-Quds al-Arabi said Zaidi’s action was “an appropriate farewell to a war criminal.”
The chief irony of this embarrassing episode is that it provided real proof of Bush’s success in transforming Iraq into a democracy.
Most Arab newspapers carried the “flying shoes” story prominently on their front pages, with commentators split on the implications of the weird assault.
Elaph.com, a prominent online newspaper, noted that Afghan journalists who attended a press conference Bush gave later at Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan were allowed to keep their shoes on. That event proceeded without incident.
Shoe jokes were being exchanged throughout the Arab world via emails and text messages. One said Israeli forces on Monday busted “a secret shoe factory belonging to Hamas in Gaza and arrested several shoe-makers.” It noted that “many of the shoes confiscated were size 10 (EU44)," the same size as the pair used against the US president.
Beating someone with a shoe is the ultimate insult in Iraqi and Arab culture. Iraqis beat the fallen statue of Saddam Hussein with their shoes after the collapse of the dictator’s regime in April 2003. Muslims are required to take off their shoes and leave them outside before they enter a mosque. This often leads to worshippers losing their shoes to others who mistake them for their own.
Iraqi journalists quoted in the Arab media said Zaidi was a Baathist supporter of Saddam who works for the Cairo-based al-Baghdadia, an anti-government Iraqi TV station. They blamed the Iraqi government for the security lapse of allowing someone like him into the press event. The TV station issued a statement distancing itself from the incident, saying Zaidi’s action was not representative of the station’s views.
While Bush remains unpopular in most of the Arab world, some comments on blogs and websites pointed out that the Iraqi journalist would have been summarily executed had he attempted something similar on Saddam.
The bizarre incident also drew some admiration for the quick reflexes that allowed Bush to successfully dodge both shoes hurled at him. But the chief irony of this embarrassing episode is that it provided real proof of Bush’s success in transforming Iraq into a democracy. Not that the president contemplated freedom of expression going this far.
Blogger Kazimi predicts an ultimate vindication of Bush’s Iraq war: “Give it twenty years or so, and a main thoroughfare in Baghdad will be called George Bush Avenue. Or maybe that's just the name of my driveway. Anyway, there will be a big sign and all.”
Salameh Nematt is the international editor of The Daily Beast. He is the former Washington bureau chief for the international Arab daily Al Hayat, where he reported on US foreign policy, the war in Iraq, and the US drive for democratization in the broader Middle East. He has also written extensively on regional and global energy issues and their political implications.
The Right Dumps Carrie
Jacob Bernstein is a senior reporter at The Daily Beast. Previously, he was a features writer at WWD and W Magazine. He has also written for New York magazine, Paper, and The Huffington Post.
What's Joe's Problem?
Lloyd Grove is editor at large for The Daily Beast. He is also a frequent contributor to New York magazine and was a contributing editor for Condé Nast Portfolio. He wrote a gossip column for the New York Daily News from 2003 to 2006. Prior to that, he wrote the Reliable Source column for the Washington Post, where he spent 23 years covering politics, the media, and other subjects.
Geithner's Stock Plummeting
Jeff Madrick is a contributor to the New York Review of Books and a former economics columnist for the New York Times. He is editor of Challenge Magazine, visiting professor of humanities at Cooper Union, and senior fellow at the New School's Schwartz Center for Economic Policy Analysis. He is the author of Taking America, The End of Affluence (Random House) and The Case for Big Government.
Qaddafi Struts In
Salameh Nematt is an international writer for The Daily Beast. He is the former Washington bureau chief for the international Arab daily Al Hayat, where he reported on US foreign policy, the war in Iraq, and the US drive for democratization in the broader Middle East. He has also written extensively on regional and global energy issues and their political implications.
The Pharaoh Comes to Washington
Salameh Nematt is an international writer for The Daily Beast. He is the former Washington bureau chief for the international Arab daily Al Hayat, where he reported on US foreign policy, the war in Iraq, and the US drive for democratization in the broader Middle East. He has also written extensively on regional and global energy issues and their political implications.
Iran's Nervous Neighbors
Salameh Nematt is an international writer for The Daily Beast. He is the former Washington bureau chief for the international Arab daily Al Hayat, where he reported on US foreign policy, the war in Iraq, and the US drive for democratization in the broader Middle East. He has also written extensively on regional and global energy issues and their political implications.
Which brings up an interesting point: where were all these brave heroes when Saddam was in power? Probably part of the 98% that voted for him.
The journalist's action was inelegant. At the same time, undeniably, he scored a kind of scoop.
Bush though was unwise. He forgot that a criminal should never revisit the scene of his crimes.
"But the chief irony of this embarrassing episode is that it provided a real proof of Bush's success in transforming Iraq into a democracy."
Good Point.
um... I think they were in Abu Ghraib? (e.g. http://www.ashbrook.org/publicat/oped/alt/04/abughraib.html) The real questions are when do the shoes show up on eBay and when does the guy get disappeared by the Iraqi government.
Can we PLEASE stop suffixing every political scandal name with -gate? Please? It only made sense the first time because that was the NAME OF THE HOTEL. Do these headline writers think they are being cute and inventive? Because I assure you, it isn't.
George W. Bush is such a ridiculous embarrassment for our country.
Actually, that shoe-throwing Saddam-supporting reporter is an embarrassment to the Arab world.
Irony? That people in free countries protest?
There are lots of explanations as to why George Bush has been treated so shabbily, but this 'reporter' like Gov Blagojevich has had his corrupt system disturbed and he's irrationally self righteous.
Iraq is no more "democratic" today than it was when Saddam was in power. It is just a question of which groups of people are enjoying greater liberties than others, why, and how the dominance of those groups within the society is viewed by the Iraqis and the world.
Under Saddam, ironically enough, gay people just to cite one example lived in less fear for their daily survival than they do in present day Iraq. You can't participate in a democracy if, because your sexual orientation has become known to your town or city, your own family congratulates those that finish you off in an honor killing. This is going on in Iraq; hardly anybody cares. The plight of gay Iraqis is barely if at all reported on in the United States. There is nobody of influence in the Bush administration that cares about this question in the least. Gay rights in the Arab world are not flourishing, whether they liked Saddam, whether they like Bush, they are not genuinely interested in human rights; they are interested in seeing their own narrow agendas fulfilled.
Mob rule and democracy are not the same phenomenon.
And, it is infantile and sub-civilized to go looking for a "vindication" of a war.
This incident symbolize the change of president, telling Bush to 'shoo off'. It reflects the gratitude of the welcoming Iraqese for the years of turmoil. And more importantly, it is a personal thank you and goodbye gift from a bitch.
.................................
http://thesuffocate.blogspot.com/
http://alexius-locker.blogspot.com/
Dana Perino shows up at a press conference with no make-up today so as to show off a slight bruise that could have easily been covered up. No swelling at all.
So one has to ask... Why would she do that? My guess is there was just a little too much fellow feeling between the Arab and American street yesterday. Quick... pull out a woman with a black eye so as to gin up some anger.
We are all shoe throwers now!Too bad he missed!
ScottRose; you are right.
I would just add that the status of women in these societies is equally horrendous, and frequently worse. Genital mutilation and child marriage is commonplace, to only name two.
Few give a damn, or, are scared to death of offending these Arab and/or Muslim countries, so stand by while these crimes are being committed in frightening numbers.
First the rock throwers and now the shoe throwers. Whose idea was it to spend a trillion dollars on this place?
Now playing nationwide in Iraq, George Bush in "Sole Man".
The problem is that he is a journalist. Journalists are supposed to leave those personal feelings at the door - it is their credo. If you want to "get" someone, you are supposed to do it in words and with facts.
By doing this, we run the risk that more journalists will be rejected from press conferences, and that is not a good thing.
As an Iraqi reading this I can't be but stunned, well Americans and American media always twist stories, your media is the epitome of hypocrisy.
1- Throwing your shoes at any one in any culture is a direct annihilation and I think it's too bad it didn't hit that demented criminal Georege W. Bush.
so please avoid twisting it around making it sound that it's an 'Iraqi culture' as opposed to your culture.
2- The Iraqi government and others who condemned the act are mere puppets who were installed by the American regime in Iraq right after the Invasion.
3- face it, you guys can't stand it that a NON ANGLO SAXON ( WASP) nation whom you look down upon perceiving us as savage uncivilized beasts in your media, took a stand and Insulted your President on IRAQI soil.
Now had Saddam walked into the United States Im sure you would have done alot more, I mean you guys had his photo's on toilet paper etc, which is equally demeaning.
DEMOCRACY? , please don't make me laugh, its either you are demented, primitive, uneducated or pure stupidity is the common denominator that unifies you all, your precious BUSH didn't invade Iraq because he wanted to install democracy in Iraq, he merely had this plan for economic and mainly a strategic point and oil, hence the AMERICAN soldiers allowed all Iraqi government institutions to be burned down except the Ministry of Oil, you allowed our Museums to be looted etc etc.
Now let's move on to your dear armies accomplishments, they raped, killed, murdered and tortured people and none of you seem to have even bothered to condemn.
It's pure racism embedded with playing on words, it's ok for you to do as you please but some colored third world country stands up and you starting whining about it.
Back to those Iraqis who condemned the act they are mere hypocrites who fear that BUSHY might get mad and remove them from power.
As for the individual who talked about Homosexuality, well your AMERICAN MEDIA again didn't inform you that the incidents that took place where in Shiite neighborhoods where Iranian militia's are active and they did that cleansing and it's not happening all over Baghdad or Iraq.
Democracy in the United States, please your American based Miss Universe organization doesn't accept an entry from Iraq because of politics, they say its not feasible.
All I can say is he missed. Oh well, that will be an image that will live forever. I wonder if he'll put it in his library.
I'm reminded of Kruschev banging his shoe on the table during some diplomatic meeting many years ago.
Using one's shoes to make a political point seems to be a universal human urge.
Thank you.
As a first time user, your comment has been submitted for review. It can take anywhere from a few hours to a day or two for your comment to be reviewed, depending on the time of week and the volume of comments we receive.
Please log in to leave comments.