Cheat Sheet

The Best In Brief

2010
2
10
FEBRUARY 2010
S
M
T
W
T
F
S
 
123456
78910
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
 
 
 
 
 
 
Whistleblower

Brutal Navy Hazing Rituals Probed

The Navy's dirtiest hazing rituals are out in the open—but are they the actions of a single "rogue unit," or a pattern of abuse? Following news that female sailor Jennifer Valdivia committed suicide amid a hazing scandal with the Navy's Bahrain dog-handling unit, Joseph Rocha, a member from the same unit, penned a shocking Washington Post column outlining his own terrorized experience, including being forced to simulate oral sex on his superiors and being locked in feces-filled dog kennels for hours on end. Rocha, who is gay and came out after his service, blames Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell for promoting a culture that glosses over sexual abuses: “You can’t sexually assault someone who doesn’t exist.” Now, CNN reports that the Valdivia and Rocha weren’t alone: An internal Navy report documented more than 90 hazing abuses, including sailors "hog-tied," "force-fed liver dog treats," and "duct-taped to a chair, rolled outside, and then left in a dog kennel until released." CNN found sailors who confirmed Rocha's report of abuses from commanding officer Michael Toussaint (Valdivia was Toussaint's second-in-command) who promoted an "atmosphere of fear" that included forcing sailors to simulate oral sex on their superiors and making a video of a "cat fight" between several scantily clad female sailors. Toussaint has since been promoted, and Rocha says he still "loves the Navy," arguing that his experience in Bahrain "is not a representation of the military." Sen. Joe Sestak (D-PA)—himself a Navy veteran—has condemned the “rogue unit” and demanded recourse.

Posted at 6:05 PM, Oct 12, 2009
Save it
|
Email
|
Facebook
|
Twitter
|
Digg
|
|
print
|
Cheat Sheet Worthy?
Thumb Up
(%)  |  
Thumb Down
(%)    
Comments ()

Plantagenet

Hazing is bad and should be ended, but the liberals will use these tragic events as an excuse for yet another feminist jihad against the entire male-dominated military.

|
|
Reply
|
6:17 pm, Oct 12, 2009

crymeariver

What does forcing MEN to "simulate oral sex on his superiors" have to do with "feminist jihad"?

|
|
Reply
|
6:54 pm, Oct 12, 2009

Plantagenet

1. Hazing is bad. Don't you know that already?

2. You must be thinking of Lawrence Summers, Obama's economic advisor, who said women are inferior.


|
7:25 pm, Oct 12, 2009

This user is no longer registered.

n--Y--morecowbell
|
9:19 pm, Oct 12, 2009

SandraZ8122

I have to say Plantagenet, I have been in camp with girls and they depanced me they called it panced. Then they all came crying to me in church and said they were sorry, yes it was a church camp.

At the same time I have been friends with boys that told me horror tales that made my pancing look minor.

You have to admit since the churches and orphanages and military whenever they get a bunch of men or boys together they are much braver in gangs or groups or lots or whatever.

CRIME IS MOSTLY COMMITTED BY MEN, women as a rule don't rape each other, but it is getting worse but men, hell the word "Bugger" The ships bugger refers to the guy the rest of the crew bugger, that is where we got STDs and epidemics where ever the men landed in Europe or in America, it comes from buggering

|
|
Reply
7:13 pm, Oct 12, 2009

tankertodd

Agreed in it shouldn't be treated as a woman/man thing but a people thing. Gender doesn't make this any less disgusting or wrong and I would guess gender doesn't play a role.

|
|
Reply
11:45 pm, Oct 12, 2009

connie47

Huh? First, it isn't a political liberal/conservative issue. But if it were, you'd find that the conservatives are the ones who don't want women in the military and don't want gays in the military, NOT the liberals.

And what's with the cheap shot attempt to tie the word "jihad" to the word "liberal?" That kind of propagandistic word association makes you look ignorant.

|
|
Reply
5:43 am, Oct 13, 2009

mcmchugh99

I have heard of hazing rituals for "new guys" in the military, but nothing nearly this bad.

One story I heard from the army was that they would hang a 'new guy" out the window by his heels and make him shout over and over again "We're a team. We're a team. We're a team". Of course, basic training is one long hazing ritual in many ways.

On our first day of basic training, they made us run up and down the stairs carrying all our clothes and gear and stand at attention, then some drill sergeant would blow a whistle and make us do it again. Then they would teach you to stand at attention and parade rest, and that a sergeant was not an officer. "Don't call me 'sir', I work for a living!") Mostly, it was stuff like that--a lot of mind games, too--but there was always a purpose.

I never saw any physical abuse in basic training, except the time when a white guy yelled at his black squad leader "I ain't takin' no orders from a nigger!", and then hit him with a rifle butt. Immediately, a drill sergeant ran over and stopped it, and this guy was a giant cracker from Louisiana who bragged about knowing more than we did even though he hadn't graduated from the second grade. Anyway, he laid the white guy out cold with one punch, saying "You don't hit my squad leaders." Probably a good thing that he did, or it might have led to a race riot.

Those are just some of the things I saw in the army, but never anything like what is being described in this article.

|
|
Reply
6:39 pm, Oct 12, 2009

jst4horses

Hazing should not be called hazing. It should be called what it is: bullying, assaults, criminal acts.

If the great "they" think it is so fun, let them put on high heels and skimpy underware and make a movie of themselves, Let them do all the other things they think up to do to others.

Those in groups who are afraid to stand up and say stop this and go tell are just as guilty and should be charged as well.

Whether in junior high gang initaitations, or college frats, or sororities where I have heard they DO make young women perform oral sex on homeless and others they find in the streets, on tape, or in the military, it is a crime and needs to have a zero tolerance and be stopped.

|
|
Reply
|
6:57 pm, Oct 12, 2009

SandraZ8122

jst4horses

Just who are you gonna tell? Get real, you squeal and they will get you even worse, and the commanding officers know about it, they were hazed themselves and they won't do shit about it. they are all in on it, get real.

|
|
Reply
7:16 pm, Oct 12, 2009

whynot

If the commander was promoted where is the accountability in the military? Deployed or not shouldn't he be brought up for court martial? Sadly, this is probably not the only military dictatorship unit in our forces and the leadership is promoted from within the ranks and protects its own. His second in command commits suicide and he is promoted, that sends a clear message to whose back was being protected by the chain of command. President Obama as commander-in-chief you need to get Defense Secretary Gates on all the military officers to discipline any such activity and court martial any personnel found to be forcing this action on soldiers who decide to protect and defend our country. They are part of our country and should be protected and defended also.

|
|
Reply
8:21 pm, Oct 12, 2009

matthewbenzor

When is this bullshit going to stop, what happened to just joining and be left alone to be the best you can be, Whats happen to our military.My brother when he joined the marine corp he told me they gave him a blanket party in basic training because he had alittle stutter, and his DI was putting pressure on the unit because of him,so they at nite while he was asleep wrapped him in his blanket and each one in his unit put a bar of soap in a sock or with a fist and hit him in the gut and when he told this story he cried. He died from cancer just recently.Something is wrong at the top of the command and something needs to be done or heads need to "roll"....

|
|
Reply
8:54 pm, Oct 12, 2009

mandy2009

I am looking for a relationships with military! I found a best place for military admirers to interact with each other. Occupation is not a problem. Check it out. ~~____KissMilitary . C O M_____

|
|
Reply
10:37 pm, Oct 12, 2009

jojo12

The commander shouldn't be demoted, he should be kicked out. What happened to these service people is not a lone incident & should not be tolerated by the Sec. of Defense or the President. There have been times when I have questioned the honesty of citizens of countries, where we are at war, when they report being abused by members of the military. I no longer question their honesty. If they do it to their own, they sure as hell do it to civilians who fear them.

|
|
Reply
11:00 pm, Oct 12, 2009

tankertodd

What is it about Navy dog handling units that requires such treatment? Are they some kind of super-elite commando force that requires mental and physical toughness?
Of course not - like jst4horses said this isn't hazing. It's abuse, pure and simple. Heads will roll for this, as well they should. Reminds me of Schofield's Definition of Discipline, which plebes at West Point memorize: http://www.west-point.org/family/bicent/plebe.html

|
|
Reply
11:43 pm, Oct 12, 2009

exploora

What I see that goes on around a small town military town, I think there is an element that is part of the culture.

I think part of it though is it not supposed to be taken literally, you are supposed to think it is a joke, but not everyone takes it like a joke.

And that is where the fine line comes in. Just like the line there is no atheist in a foxhole. That line doesn't mean what it says literally, it means people in a situation, or preparing for a situation, where you could die, or get mutilated, then that kind of "play" in a sick way, makes sense. It is like letting of being civilized, so it doesn't matter in more. I am guessing.

|
|
Reply
|
12:00 am, Oct 13, 2009

exploora

I meant: It is like letting GO of being civilized, so it doesn't matter in more. I am guessing.

I think war culture can lead to some forms of depravity, if a person gives up in believing in something better.

|
|
Reply
12:04 am, Oct 13, 2009

Jenns1mom

It makes no sense!!! This was not preparing anyone for anything!!! And It was certanly not a joke, My daughter was abused, then then told she was responsible for not stopping it, she believed in the military with her whole heart and in the end she ended up taking her life, She was hit, spit on, and made to do things that no one should have to do, Then they being blamed her for letting letting it happen! Some of her final words...A smile can hide a thousand Tears, I am tired of pretending and...I love the Military I just wish the Navy was still a part of it. This was no Joke!!! It was Torture for her !!!

|
|
Reply
10:27 pm, Dec 9, 2009

mcmchugh99

The worst thing I ever saw in training happened in AIT, but it was not hazing so much as a hate crime--at least, that's what it would be called today.

Three KKK guys beat up a black guy and threw him down the stairs when they found out he was gay. The captain moved him out of the barracks after that, to a room on the first floor near the company office. Soon after this, the guy slashed his wrists and drank a bottle of turpentine. I don't know if he lived or died; the last I saw of him was when he was being taken away in an ambulance.

I knew who did it. Many people did, but no one turned them in. Had I been older and more sure of myself, I would have, but I was 19. Even then, I can remember walking by the base Judge Advocate's office and thinking maybe I should turn in these three KKK guys, but I was scared of what would happen to me--and I wasn't sure that the army really wanted to do anything about it. This was many years ago, and I didn't think anyone was really going to go out on a limb to help a black guy who was also gay, especially if that meant arresting three white men and court martialing them.

Anyway, I did nothing. No one did anything.

I have never been able to get this incident out of my mind, though. It still makes me wonder why any gay person would even want to be in the military or fight for this society at all.

|
|
Reply
12:17 am, Oct 13, 2009

boredwell

I just read a story about a sorority that beat and starved pledges. Years ago, 60 Minutes exposed a hazing ritual that involved painting shoe polish on the genitals of marines graduating boot camp causing them to burn. And a rugby team hazes newbies by urinating on them. At an exclusive girls school, upperclassmen rubbed dog feces in freshman students' faces. One of the hazers admitted her mother helped her collect the doggie materiel. Several years ago, a young man and his cronies raped two boys with broom sticks at a high school football camp as part of a hazing "tradition" that seriously injured one victim. In each of these cases, those who complained of the treatment were ostracized. These, including Mr Rocha's experience in Bahrain, are not just offensive and degrading hazing rituals. The master minds who inflict these abuses suffer from megalomania, sadism and prurience. I'm not sure how exactly Mr Rocha's sexuality comes into play here since he states that ALL personnel regardless of gender and gender preference were equally abused. And there seems to have been no method to the madness. Had Master Sergeant Toussaint, the leader of Mr Rocha's unit, treated the canines in the same manner he treated his troops, the outcry would have created a tsunami of outrage. What an irony.

|
|
Reply
1:16 am, Oct 13, 2009

Cymatic

It never fails to amaze me how brutally homophobic men can perpetrate gay s&m hazing rituals. In my town the same hockey players who drove around looking for "faggots" to beat up had hazing rituals that involved forcing new recruits to eat crackers that were lodged in another player's butt, and tied a bag around their genitals which they would try to throw hockey pucks into. I really believe that most of those who are violently homophobic are suppressing a gay streak of their own.

|
|
Reply
|
2:13 am, Oct 13, 2009

hockeydog

Those kinds of hockey-puck-heads give us hockey-dogs indigestion.

|
|
Reply
6:40 am, Oct 13, 2009

ceejaecee

I was hazed as part of a USN Chief's initiation and spent a few days in the hospital. The men responsible got a "slap on the wrist" for trying to drown me (one female against three men). The Navy, from the command Master Chief up to Chief of Staff "covered-up" the entire "incident". To this day I suffer with PTSD, depression, and anxiety. Plus, the JAG report NEVER made it past the command or to NICIS. This happened in Orlando, FL at the Naval Reserve Center. EMCM Todd Grantier was the command Master Chief.

|
|
Reply
8:26 am, Feb 4, 2010
Leave a comment

Thank you.
As a first time user, your comment has been submitted for review. It can take anywhere from a few hours to a day or two for your comment to be reviewed, depending on the time of week and the volume of comments we receive.

View Comments
View Full Cheat Sheet