Though Sarah Brice won the heart of actor Charlie O'Connell on
The Bachelor's seventh season in 2005, their romance did not last. The two broke up in 2007, reconciled the following year, and then split for good this past April. Despite their separation, ABC producers allowed Brice to keep her $20,000 engagement ring because she stayed with O'Connell for two years (apparently, that's the unofficial reality TV rule),
In Touch Weekly reported. In September, the tabloid revealed that the former TV personality decided to auction off the ring on eBay in an effort to gain a sense of closure. "I need to move on, and looking at that ring wasn't helping matters," Brice told the magazine. "It seemed like a bad omen to keep it. It's a gorgeous ring, though, and someone will be very lucky to get it." The starting bid was just $5,000.