Content Section

Romney Scored, but Who Wins the Game?

Yes, Romney outperformed Obama in their first debate, but the president made headway with voters on issues that matter, writes Robert Shrum.
Win McNamee / Getty Images

Unhappily I was right: Mitt Romney could—and did—win the first debate. But I’m not eloquently panicked, as Andrew Sullivan was during his live blog of Obama’s defeat in Denver. The president could have put the election away; but it’s emphatically overstated, if entirely understandable, to suggest the opposite—that “[he] may even have lost the election” with “the wrong strategy … [at] the wrong moment.

The Ass Who Married the Elephant

Susannah Breslin and her husband eloped a year ago after a nine day courtship. The only problem so far: she’s a lifelong liberal Democrat, and he’s a conservative Marine Corps reservist. The conversation, she writes, never stops.
Jupiterimages via Getty Images

On November 19, 2011, my husband I eloped in Las Vegas(PDF). We’d met nine days before. In a little chapel off the Las Vegas Strip, we vowed to spend the rest of our lives together. There was no mention of our political allegiances.

Why Obama Fell Flat

The president made some good arguments but was undermined by his lack of passion. Howard Kurtz on how he let Romney win the night.
Saul Loeb, AFP / Getty Images

On paper, Barack Obama didn't have that bad a night in Denver.Unfortunately for him, debates aren't won on paper.Watching the proceedings at the University of Denver, I didn't see the split-screen reaction shots that showed the president looking down and generally looking glum.

Polls: Romney Wins

Pundits trashed President Obama’s performance in last night’s debate—and instant polls show that voters agree. Matthew DeLuca breaks down the numbers. Plus, full debate coverage and video.
Charles Dharapak / AP Photo

Here’s an October surprise: Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney was a knockout in last night’s first presidential debate, according to two instant polls conducted Wednesday night. It was an evening of defied expectations.

Stuff Mitt Likes

At the conclusion of the third and final presidential debate, Mitt Romney reiterated—multiple times—that he loves teachers. Of course, Romney has been a bit polyamorous throughout this election. From coal to cars to Big Bird, here are a few of Mitt’s favorite things.
Summit Entertainment ; AP Photo (2) ; Getty Images

From teachers to lakes to cars to Big Bird, these are a few more of Mitt’s favorite things.

The Rockefeller Republican Wins Big

Charlie Neibergall / AP Photo

There is no question that Mitt Romney won this debate, and won it big. He was crisp, and he struck a good balance of being on the offensive without being offensive. Obama was hardly even there half the time. He seemed as if he just wandered in off the street.

Why Obama Lost

CNN Live Shot/RNC Research

Mitt Romney dominated and Barack Obama stumbled in Denver Wednesday night. What went right for Romney and wrong for the president? These things:Romney arrived with a strategic plan; Obama didn’t. Romney was quick on his feet; Obama slow on his feet.

‘He May Have Lost the Election’

This was supposed to be a debate, not a wonkish lecture. And Romney’s well-crafted punches are going to sting Obama for a while. Read Andrew Sullivan’s debate live blog.
Michael Reynolds, Pool / AP Photo

Look: you know how much I love the guy, and you know how much of a high-information viewer I am, and I can see the logic of some of Obama's meandering, weak, professorial arguments. But this was a disaster for the president for the key people he needs to reach, and his effete, wonkish lectures may have jolted a lot of independents into giving Romney a second look.

Obama’s Big Whimper

The 51-year-old hope-and-change wonder boy looked worn out, uncomfortable, and embarrassed to be there, at times wrinkling his face as if suffering severe gastric distress. Michael Medved on the four big surprises from the Denver Donnybrook.
Getty Images (2)

The first presidential debate between Barack Obama and Mitt Romney, otherwise known as “The Denver Donnybrook,” offered the rarest of pleasures for attentive viewers: a series of utterly unexpected developments that could shock and shove the perpetually close campaign in dramatically new directions.

Mitt Offense Trumped Obama Defense

While Romney took the fight to Obama, the president played it safe, avoiding clashing with the ideas advanced by the Republican nominee. Obama played not to lose—and lost.
Eric Gay / AP

We learned last night that there are significant policy differences between President Obama and Mitt Romney, and that at least in this first debate, Romney is better at defending his policies than the president is. Both men avoided the temptation for the trite and gave us a detailed debate over the economy, tax policy, spending, entitlements, energy, and education, which exposed the vast differences between the two in one of the most substantive presidential debates in their history.

The Best Big Bird Tweets

Mitt Romney said during the presidential debate that he “loves” Big Bird—despite his threat to cut PBS’s budget. The GOP nominee’s remark lit up the Twitterverse afterward, and The Daily Beast gathered the best of the tweets.
AP Photos (2)

This may go down in history as the Big Bird debate. Just minutes after Mitt Romney’s “I love Big Bird!” comment, the yellow bird was Twitter’s man of the hour. Parody accounts and tweets spread like wildfire, furiously rallying behind the bird, whom Romney threatened to put out of a job by cutting government subsidies for PBS.

Seven Unemployed Big Bird Memes

Forget Obama. Big Bird was the real loser at Denver’s debate. Romney set off a Twitter outcry when he threatened to slash PBS subsidies—and a thousand new Internet memes were born. See seven of the best.

Forget Obama. Big Bird was the real loser in Denver after Romney threatened to slash PBS subsidies.

The Debate Body Language

The pundits may be calling Denver a slam-dunk for Romney, but David B. Givens, who analyzed the candidates’ mannerisms, disagrees: the governor looked ‘aggressive and manic, simultaneously,’ while Obama was ‘cool.’
AFP-Getty Images (4)

The governor was manic and the president was, well, presidential during Wednesday night’s donnybrook in Denver.“All in all, Barack Obama was measured and cool, nonverbally, while Mitt Romney was aggressive, interrupting, and speaking over the host many times,” said Gonzaga University anthropologist David B.

The Debate Fact-Check

Romney’s figure for the rise in health-care costs was wrong. Obama’s $4 trillion number was inaccurate. The Daily Beast turns to the Internet's most reliable fact-checkers for the candidates’ most glaring errors.
AP Photo (2)

Romney: “Health-care costs have gone up by $2,500 a family.”Factcheck.org, the Annenberg Public Policy Center’s accuracy policy, say this is false. They cite a Kaiser Family Foundation survey (PDF) that found that between 2010 and 2011, the average health-insurance premium cost for families increased by $1,300, not $2,500, and point out that even between 2009 and 2011 the increase in average cost was only $1,700.

Romney Won and the Truth Lost

Romney lied brazenly about everything—notably on taxes—yet over and over again an honest but listless and meandering Obama failed to effectively challenge him.
Charlie Neibergall / AP Photo

At a doctor’s appointment today, I was warned that, being seven and a half months pregnant, I should try not to get too stressed out watching tonight’s presidential debate. Fat chance. For the first hour and 10 minutes, watching Mitt Romney dominate his confrontation with President Obama was such an excruciating exercise in frustration that I probably should have turned it off and taken to my bed.

‘Attacking Me Is Not An Agenda’

Throughout his campaign, Mitt Romney has attacked President Obama for, well, attacking him—and he doubled down on this approach Monday night: 'Attacking me is not an agenda,' Romney scolded.

  1. Giddyup! Obama's Big Bayonet Slam Play

    Giddyup! Obama's Big Bayonet Slam

  2. ‘The 1980s Called…’ Play

    ‘The 1980s Called…’

  3. ‘We Can’t Kill Our Way Out’ Play

    ‘We Can’t Kill Our Way Out’

Must-See Moments

Foreign Policy Showdown

Best Moments From the Final Presidential Debate

Best Moments From the Final Presidential Debate

Obama and Romney duked it out on foreign policy Monday night. Watch the most memorable moments.

Interactive

Ground Game

Obama Opens Up Big Lead

Obama Opens Up Big Lead

As of mid-October, the Obama campaign has 755 offices nationwide for its get-out-the-vote effort—nearly three times as many as the Romney campaign. PLUS: John Avlon and Michael Keller break down what the office edge could mean on election day.

super-pac-ad-tracker-tease

Election Ad Tracker

View, rate, and fact check the latest campaign ads.

Watch This

History Lesson

7 Debate Wins and Fails

7 Debate Wins and Fails

Dukakis and the rape question. Reagan and his age joke. See the highest and lowest moments of debates past.

LOL

Debate Memes

The Best Horses & Bayonets Photos

The Best Horses & Bayonets Photos

Big Bird, Binders Full of Women, and, now, Horses and Bayonets. The funniest meme photos from the latest debate catchphrase.

Watch This!

Art Imitates Life

10 Greatest Fictional Debates

10 Greatest Fictional Debates

Ahead of Tuesday’s presidential debate, a look at the more entertaining showdowns from film and TV.

Plus

Full Debate Coverage

The House of Representatives' Confusing 3-Headed Immigration Monster

The House of Representatives' Confusing 3-Headed Immigration Monster

The Obama Scandals

Stop Calling Obama Aloof!

IRS, BENGHAZI, AP

How Obama Handles Crisis

Moving On

An ‘SNL’ Exodus?

Huddled Masses

A Nation of Immigrants?