When Dawson’s Creek made its debut in 1998, it was considered scandalous teen television. Filled with talk of maturing body parts, excessive kissing, and inappropriate relationships (Pacey and his teacher, anyone?), the show featured a cast of young actors. However, twins Andie and Jack, played by Meredith Monroe and Kerr Smith, were almost twice their characters’ ages when they joined the cast. Kerr was 32 when the show wrapped, and Monroe was 36 when she appeared in the series finale.