Video

The Cost of Legalizing Marijuana
El Cerrito Police Chief Scott Kirkland talks about the true cost of legalizing marijuana in California. Sure, the state will get extra tax money and Frito Lay stocks will rise, but can emergency rooms deal with the burnout fallout?
the-cost-of-legalizing-marijuana
  |  
August 22, 2009 | 11:48am
Comments ()

swilli01

Where does this guy live?

|
|
Reply
|
12:44 pm, Aug 22, 2009

This user is no longer registered.

|
|
Reply
4:35 pm, Aug 23, 2009

cenerentolo

another reactionary.

when i was on the debate team and had a big argument that i wanted to prove, i would look for words written down that could be used as evidence. one of the things i developed in my character as a result of that tendency toward fallacy and sophistic thinking was the need to be aware of both sides of an argument, aping thomas aquinas.

without that discipline you become inductive, you argue straw men and red-herrings. sometimes you even lie.

in countries with more evolved ideas about drug policies in effect, their drug treatment needs have declined.

further, the treatment for alcohol and tobacco make up the vast lion's share of costs and deaths.....

more grass problems in the EMERGENCY room??? PUHLEASE

i would need a qualification, as we know, the police are allowed to lie.

this whole thing is like a bastardized "gateway" argument, at best.

finally, even if the facts and figures werent bunk that an audience of children could see through if they wished, with more people in our jails than in russia at the height of stalin, there might be costs that he failed to mention..

|
|
Reply
2:53 pm, Aug 22, 2009

darladoon

all of the available empirical data on the legalization of marijuana (portugal, holland, even canada) completely rejects all of the counter-arguments this guy is making.



|
|
Reply
5:47 pm, Aug 22, 2009

This comment has been removed by The Daily Beast's editors.

|
|
Reply
5:56 pm, Aug 22, 2009

keemia

One of the counter-arguments the two guys failed to make is that the California system is stretched to the seams from the cost of capturing, prosecuting, and jailing small-time dope sellers. The "3 strikes" law is keeping hordes of people behind bars for selling very small amounts of marijuana. Add to that commercialization of the Calif jails "to save money", and you have a completely broken system. And who pays for that? Any wonder why the state is going bankrupt?

|
|
Reply
7:16 pm, Aug 22, 2009

deegeezee

yes, but the Tax Argument hold absolutely no water.
1) if legalized, people will simply grow their own.
2) drug dealers are notorious for a lot of things... paying taxes isn't one of them.

and keemia, if the 3 strikes law is the problem, then *that's* what you change.

|
|
Reply
|
9:32 pm, Aug 22, 2009

Dimlah

Flawed argument is flawed.

Basic economic theory suggests that the most effective production method is large scale. Were Marijuana to be legalized, the vast majority of the herb on the street would come from giant, multi-acre plantations farmed by agri-businesses. Alcohol is heavily taxed but the moonshine industry isn't exactly booming. This is because a giant factory that pays taxes will always be more cost efficient than a small bathtub that doesn't.

|
|
Reply
11:58 pm, Aug 22, 2009
Leave a comment

Thank you.
As a first time user, your comment has been submitted for review. It can take anywhere from a few hours to a day or two for your comment to be reviewed, depending on the time of week and the volume of comments we receive.

View Comments
Previous
Next
2009
08
22
AUGUST 2009
S
M
T
W
T
F
S
Week of August 16, 2009   Calendar
 
Tarantino: One Tricky 'Basterd'
Want to know why Brad Pitt's Basterd character has a scar on his neck? Too bad, Tarantino ain't telling. Because you pay $10 to not be told things in a movie, right? Source...
August 22, 2009 | 6:02pm
 
Trailer: Inglourious Basterds
Tarantino's latest, Inglourious Basterds, opened this weekend, and is a wild, violent ride—but it's nothing compared to the real story of Nazi-hunting WWII soldiers.
August 22, 2009 | 3:43pm
 
Women's Judo Pioneer Honored
Fifty years after she was stripped of her judo medal because of her gender, Rena "Rusty" Kanokogi, a fighting champ and equal rights pioneer, finally received her much-dese...
August 22, 2009 | 1:25pm
 
The Cost of Legalizing Marijuana
El Cerrito Police Chief Scott Kirkland talks about the true cost of legalizing marijuana in California. Sure, the state will get extra tax money and Frito Lay stocks will r...
August 22, 2009 | 11:48am
 
Are Men Funnier than Women?
Rachel Sklar talks to Daily Show co-creator Lizz Winstead about the provocative topic of why there aren't more women working behind the scenes in comedy. Is it because wome...
August 22, 2009 | 10:01am
 
Kingsley: Acting's Like the Military
In case you missed it, Ben Kingsley was on Charlie Rose this week and said that if he wasn't an actor, he would probably be in the military because the two professions are ...
August 22, 2009 | 7:28am
 
Paterson: Media Exploiting Race
On a radio show Friday, N.Y. Gov. David Paterson criticized the media for exploiting racial stereotypes in its coverage of him. And he says the next victim is President Oba...
August 21, 2009 | 7:59pm
 
Bear Mascot Drops Runner
Melaine Walker, who won the women's 400-meter hurdles at the World Athletics Championships Thursday, was taken on an unfortunate victory lap by Berlino the Bear mascot who,...
August 21, 2009 | 7:44pm