Content Section

Media Hype About Mitt Romney’s Iowa Showing Is Wrong

The pundits suggest a three-way tie is bad for Mitt. Peter Beinart on what the talking heads are getting wrong—and how far, how fast the ex–Massachusetts governor has come.

When watching election-night media commentary, always remember: pundits have a bias. They want an exciting race.

Mitt Romney sailing merrily toward a Republican nomination that many considered foreordained is not exciting. So all over cable television talking heads are claiming that Romney’s inability to win more than a quarter of the vote in Iowa constitutes a loss.

Romney

Khue Bui for Newsweek

Huh? Iowa is such a bad state for Romney, dominated as it is by Christian-right activists who have long distrusted him, that he considered not even competing there. He’s much stronger in New Hampshire, where economic conservatives predominate, and in the big states where what you need is gobs of money. For Romney, a three-way tie for first place in Iowa is manna from heaven. It’s especially lovely because the two people he’s tied with—Rick Santorum and Ron Paul—probably can’t win the nomination. Santorum has no money and has hardly faced a negative ad. Paul is loathed by virtually the entire GOP establishment.

To understand how well Romney has done, consider his success against the bigger-name conservatives. If anyone had told pundits a year ago that Romney would win four times as much support as Michele Bachmann in Iowa, or six months ago that he’d get two and a half times as much support as Rick Perry, or one month ago that he’d get double the support of Newt Gingrich, they would have been astonished. Now commentators are suggesting he didn’t do well enough.

Republican presidential history is littered with moderate frontrunners who got creamed in Iowa—George H.W. Bush in 1988, John McCain in 2008—and still won the nomination. In 2008, Mitt Romney invested heavily there and lost by 9 points. This year, he kept expectations low and managed a tie for first place with two candidates who almost certainly can’t beat him.

That may be boring, but it’s pretty darn good.

You Might Also Like

Comments

What the GOP Women Are Up To

GOP women put together an ad to tell voters where they come from-and where they'd like the country to go.

  1. Stop the Ridiculous SuperPAC Ads Play

    Stop the Ridiculous SuperPAC Ads

  2. Powell: 'No Problem' with Gay Marriage Play

    Powell: 'No Problem' with Gay Marriage

  3. Who is Mitt Romney? Play

    Who is Mitt Romney?

Too Close to Call?

A Tight Election Has Disaster Potential

The Looming Electoral Armageddon?

The Looming Electoral Armageddon?

What if Obama wins the popular vote, but not the Electoral College? Michael Medved’s nightmare scenario.

A-List Donors

Will Hollywood Save Private Ryan?

The Swamps of Jersey

How Much Will Booker's Comments Matter?

Skeletons

Blasts from the Past Wound Romney

Gay Marriage

Obama Knows Better

 

 

 

NBC News

Courtesy of our partners @ NBC News

Michael Tomasky

Shame on You, Booker

Shame on You, Booker

Leaders are important; so are followers. That’s a lesson Cory Booker and Richard Grenell need to learn.

Our Broken Economy

Our Broken Economy

mitt-romney-press-kurtz

Romney’s Off-Limits Campaign

With Bain, Romneycare, and Mormonism off the table, what can Mitt talk about? By Howard Kurtz.