Content Section

A Grand Bargain for Romney

Was6170163

Republican presidential hopeful Mitt Romney delivers a speech at Paramount Printing, a company going out of business, in Jacksonville, Florida, EMMANUEL DUNAND / AFP / Getty Images

At Investors.com, the always interesting Jed Graham reminds us that back in 2007, Romney economist Greg Mankiw's criticized the carried interest rule that allows Mitt Romney to pay 15% on his earnings at Bain:

Krugman hit the nail on the head with this question: ‘why does (private equity titan) Henry Kravis pay a lower tax rate on his management fees than I pay on my book royalties?’ The analogy is a good one. In both cases, a person (investment manager, author) is putting in effort today for a risky return at some point in the future. The tax treatment should be the same in the two cases.

Graham himself wonders:

Why, for example, should stock options—another form of sweat equity—be taxed as regular income while carried interest is taxed as capital gains?

Graham suggests:

Perhaps there is a route by which Romney can propose to end the tax break as part of a deal that lowers tax rates while broadening the tax base. That would narrow the gap between taxes on regular income and investment gains, thus making favorable treatment of carried interest less meaningful.

Related Stories

Comments

subscribe-to-david-frum

About David Frum

David's Book Club

Debate Reax

From The Daily Beast

Best Moments From the GOP Debate

Best Moments From the GOP Debate

Paul calls Santorum a 'fake,' Gingrich rages over the border, and more. WATCH VIDEO.

Nice Try

Specter Haunts the GOP Debate

What Surge?!

Mitt Rocks Rick

Dodge

Santorum Defuses Birth-Control Bomb

Messy

Debate Missteps

FrumForum Archive

Did Culture Wars Win the Debate?

Where's the culture wars latest battleground? Try the CNN stage at Wednesday's Arizona debate. When Rick Santorum and Mitt Romney weren't fighting each other, they double-downed on their controversial views on contraception.
  1. The Family Values Con Play

    The Family Values Con

  2. Gillibrand Takes On the 'War on Women' Play

    Gillibrand Takes On the 'War on Women'

  3. Bailout Stance the Subject of Anti-Romney Ad Play

    Bailout Stance the Subject of Anti-Romney Ad