Content Section

Obama’s Same-Sex Two-Step: Strictly Personal Embrace of Gay Marriage?

The president endorsed gay marriage on Wednesday—but took pains to stress his position as a personal one. That means official action on the statement won’t necessarily follow, says Harry Siegel.

As President Obama sought to bring his lengthy “evolution” position on the issue on gay marriage to an end Wednesday in an interview with ABC, the network’s chyron proclaimed: Obama Officially Affirms Gay Marriage Support. But the president’s remarks were carefully couched as anything but official.

While same-sex marriage advocates were mostly united in their praise of “a historic turning point,” Obama took care to present his position as a personal one—and not one that would necessarily trigger any official action in his roles as president and head of the Democratic Party.

“At a certain point, I’ve just concluded that for me personally it is important for me to go ahead and affirm that I think same-sex couples should be able to get married,” Obama told Robin Roberts (emphases mine).

“The president stressed that this is a personal position, and that he still supports the concept of states’ [sic] deciding the issue on their own,” reported ABC, which has aired excerpts of the interview but has yet to release it in full.

Thirty states have constitutional amendments banning gay marriage, while six states and Washington, D.C., legally recognize them. Obama’s interview came a day after North Carolinians overwhelmingly passed a state constitutional amendment barring not just same-sex marriages but civil unions.

It remains unclear what, if anything, Obama’s personal embrace of same-sex marriage will mean in his roles as president, and head of the Democratic Party. While prominent Democrats have called for the national party to add a plank in support of gay marriage to its platform at the convention in Charlotte in September, senior administration officials declined to tell the Huffington Post’s Sam Stein whether Obama would now push for a gay-marriage plan at the convention. The officials also said the president stood by his position that he would not sign an executive order banning discrimination against federal contractors on the basis of sexual orientation.

Obama

Saul Loeb, AFP / Getty Images

“[B]y endorsing a ‘states’ rights’ approach to same-sex marriage, Obama essentially preserves the current status quo in which a handful of states recognize same-sex marriage and many states have constitutional bans against them,” wrote Nation editor Richard Kim. “That is not marriage equality, and does not even reach the standard Obama previously embraced of equal rights and recognitions.”

It remains unclear what, if anything, Obama’s personal embrace of same-sex marriage will mean in his roles as president, and head of the Democratic Party.

The one time Obama offered a categorical answer on what may supporters see as a civil rights question was in 1996, when as a candidate for the Illinois state Senate he wrote in response to a survey from a gay paper: “I favor legalizing same-sex marriages, and would fight efforts to prohibit such marriages.”

That shorter response, far more sweeping and categorical than what he said Wednesday, was repudiated last year by White House communications director Dan Pfeiffer, who said that despite Obama’s signature, “the answers were actually filled out by someone else” and didn’t reflect Obama’s view at the time.

You Might Also Like

Newsweek

Obama's Gay Awakening

The president’s bold support shifted the mainstream. Andrew Sullivan on why it shouldn't be surprising—Obama’s life as a biracial man has deep ties to the gay experience.

Full Coverage

The Daily Beast Reports

Obama Comes Full Circle In Gay-Marriage Evolution

Obama Comes Full Circle In Gay-Marriage Evolution

The president said in 1996 that he would support legalizing gay marriage, and 16 years later became the first Oval Office holder to do just that, writes Michelle Goldberg.

Interview Bombshell

How Obama Came Out for Marriage

ANTE UP

Obama’s High-Stakes Gamble

Proud

Obama Did the Right Thing

Half Step

Obama Plays It Safe on Marriage

Obama Endorses Gay Marriage

In a major policy shift Wednesday, President Obama told ABC News’s Robin Roberts that ‘same-sex couples should be able to get married.’ The move marked the first time a sitting president has thrown his support behind gay marriage and the end of Obama's self-described 'evolution' on the issue.

  1. Biden ‘Comfortable’ With Gay Marriage Play

    Biden ‘Comfortable’ With Gay Marriage

  2. Did Obama Ignite a Culture War? Play

    Did Obama Ignite a Culture War?

  3. Was Obama Forced to Endorse Gay Marriage? Play

    Was Obama Forced to Endorse Gay Marriage?

'Rite of Passage'

My Four Gay Marriages

My Four Gay Marriages

As the debate over gay marriage rages, what marriages and weddings really mean. By David Jefferson.

Newsweek

Gay Marriage is Good for America

Gay Marriage is Good for America

As same-sex couples march down the aisle in N.Y., Andrew Sullivan reflects on his own pursuit of happiness.

Coming Out

Where Gay Marriage Is Legal

Where Gay Marriage Is Legal

From Canada to Portugal, 10 countries that allow same-sex couples to legally tie the knot.