Content Section

Mark McKinnon: An Unfair Attack on Mitt Romney’s NAACP Speech

He’s a ‘race-mongering pyromaniac’ just for saying ‘Obamacare’—the word Team Obama is selling on bumper stickers? Why Michael Tomasky belongs in the Double Standard Hall of Fame.

Romney

Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney addresses the NAACP annual convention in Houston, Texas on July 11, 2012. (Nicholas Kamm / AFP / Getty Images)

I have to say after thirty years in politics and a good bit of punditry of my own, not much shocks me. But when I read the following this week from a fellow Daily Beast columnist, Michael Tomasky, I was left sputtering: After Romney’s speech to the NAACP, “I think of him as a spineless, disingenuous, supercilious, race-mongering pyromaniac who is very poorly intentioned indeed…”

Sputter.

Now, people can have a lot of legitimate criticisms of Mitt Romney, and I have some of my own, but a “race-mongering pyromaniac?” And the evidence for this incendiary charge? Romney said the word “Obamacare.” That’s it. That’s Tomasky’s whole case upon which he has rendered Romney a racist.

If the term “Obamacare” is a pejorative, racist epithet, then Tomasky needs to rebuke the president of the United States with the same unhinged energy he used in his ugly rant against Romney. The president’s senior advisers and his campaign staff, and even President Obama himself, have embraced “Obamacare” as the now-common name for his legacy legislation, the Affordable Care Act. His campaign site is even making money off of the name “Obamacare,” selling buttons, bumper stickers, and T-shirts emblazoned with the name.

At a fundraiser in Atlanta on March 16, Obama said he didn’t mind the use of the word because it showed he does care:  “You want to call it Obamacare—that’s OK, because I do care.” Obama also used it on March 23 in a tweet: “Happy birthday to Obamacare: two years in, the Affordable Care Act is making millions of Americans’ lives better every day.” And later that day, in another tweet: “If you’re proud of Obamacare and tired of the other side using it as a dirty word, complete this sentence: #ILikeObamacare because...” It also appeared on the landing page headline for Obama’s campaign website:  “I like Obamacare.”

So, it is, apparently, not a BFD. At least not to the president, his campaign, or his supporters. They are proudly using the term “Obamacare.” But when Romney uses in a speech the same phrase the president uses, he is a “race-mongering pyromaniac.”   

Wow. That’s Double Standard Hall of Fame.

Tomasky must not have listened to all of Romney’s words at the NAACP convention or, with a hardened heart or a completely liberal bias, chose not to hear them.

The crowd responded with applause to Romney as he spoke with sincerity: “I hope to represent all Americans... I want to make this a campaign about helping the middle class… Americans of every background are asking when this economy will finally recover—and you, in particular, are entitled to an answer… On Day One, I will begin turning this economy around… ”

These are the very same words I can hear Obama speaking.

Romney admitted with humility: “The Republican Party’s record, by the measures you rightly apply, is not perfect. Any party that claims a perfect record doesn’t know history the way you know it.” And then spoke of the inspiration of his father’s work for civil rights.

Romney’s address was heartfelt and offered important messages on economic opportunity and education, critical needs today not only for African-American families but for all American families.

Mitt Romney is not a racist. This is the kind of invective that is poisoning our public discourse.

While attacking the Republican challenger as spineless, Tomasky is surprised Romney dared speak of repealing Obamacare, still a majority view of the nation and still a likely key issue in the November election. Had Romney not mentioned it, wouldn’t Tomasky have accused him of being “spineless”?

And had Tomasky listened to the speech rather than just read the transcript, he would have heard Romney go off-script to address the boos following his mention of Obamacare. He shared his concerns about the job-market impact of Obamacare, and committed to ensuring access to lower cost, good quality health care with coverage for pre-existing conditions.

Tomasky perhaps cannot admit that Mitt showed a lot of spine for showing up at the event knowing he wouldn’t get much support and would probably get booed. Obama did not even attend the event.

Reasonable people can reasonably disagree on policy. And the audience attending the convention understood that, giving the Republican candidate a standing ovation in the end.

Mitt Romney is not a racist. This is the kind of invective that is poisoning our public discourse. It is designed to be sensational for the sake of being sensational and it is highly irresponsible.  

But Tomasky is right about one thing. We did learn “a great deal about Mitt Romney” through his words—if we chose to listen.

We also learned a lot about Tomasky.

You Might Also Like

Stewart: Florida Does It Again!

On 'The Daily Show's first post-election episode, Jon Stewart questioned the Sunshine State's relevance. Sorry, Florida, we elected a president without you.

  1. Elizabeth Warren, Badass Senator Play

    Elizabeth Warren, Badass Senator

  2. How Obama Pulled It Off Play

    How Obama Pulled It Off

  3. A Hate Ad Already? Play

    A Hate Ad Already?

super-pac-ad-tracker-tease

Election Ad Tracker

View, rate, and fact check the latest campaign ads.

Election Night

Victory

President Obama Passes 300 Electoral Votes, Wins Reelection

President Obama Passes 300 Electoral Votes, Wins Reelection

Interactive

State by State

Map: Election 2012 Results

Map: Election 2012 Results

The Daily Beast’s map of the Electoral College results—updated live as they come in.

Watch This!

The Night's Best Moments

13 Must-See Moments From Election Night

13 Must-See Moments From Election Night

From Obama’s win to Akin’s defeat, Sullivan’s celebration to Rove’s meltdown, watch the most memorable moments.

Aftermath

Post-Election

Five Stages of GOP Grief

Five Stages of GOP Grief

Losing sucks—and healing is hard. Paul Begala offers advice to hurting Republicans.

Over

A Thrashing

Forward

Obama’s Second Chance

Allies

Obama’s Win, Bibi’s Loss

Party Foul

Romney Victory Party a Bust

Gender Matters

Women in the World

Three Wild Races for Women

Three Wild Races for Women

Three of the most dramatic races ended in wins for Dems Elizabeth Warren and Maggie Hassan, and a loss for the GOP’s Linda McMahon.

 

 

 

NBC News

Courtesy of our partners @ NBCNews.

Campaign-In-Review

Memorable Moments

The Election’s 20 Turning Points

The Election’s 20 Turning Points

It’s finally over! Mark McKinnon looks back on two years of big moments that changed the 2012 race.

Oui Oui

Election Victory

A Great Day for America

A Great Day for America

Obama’s reelection is a victory for intelligence, reason—and, yes, hope.

Book List

Political Picks

The Obama Vs. Romney Reading List

The Obama Vs. Romney Reading List

As the candidates face off in the election, the books they’ve read recently and their professed favorites also go head to head. Who wins?