Black and White

05.13.15 9:15 AM ET

A Black Man Hangs a White Supremacist: Tyler Shields’s Charged Photography

In Tyler Shields’ photographs the traditional victim of violent race-related injustice turns aggressor. For Shields, it’s a powerful and symbolic role reversal.

There he hangs, just feet above the water.

The white, hooded figure whose body is limp and lifeless resembles a uniformed member of the Klu Klux Klan. As he hangs, a black man securely holds the opposite end of the rope. Is he the culprit or the savior? We do not know.

Courtesy Tyler Shields

It’s an image shocking even by today’s standards: after all, the despicably archaic act of lynching still permeates today’s society. Just this week a black man in Georgia was found hanging behind a house that wasn’t his.

He had recently been questioned for the death of a white woman and, as investigators search for answers, the family refuses to accept his death as a suicide.

“Right now we are going through a real racial issue in our country,” Tyler Shields, who photographed the image for his new series Historical Fiction, told The Daily Beast. “And, to me, these things that happened in the 20s and 30s, they’re just as poignant today as they were back then.”

According to an investigation by the Equal Justice Initiative (PDF), some 3,959 blacks were lynched between 1877 and 1950 throughout the South.

The KKK and other “white mob” groups have been primary suspects in countless cases that are still being investigated today.

Yet there’s never been a documented case of anyone hanging a Klansman, according to Shields, who was curious as to how the role reversal would look and the emotional reaction it would evoke in the viewer.

“I’ve always loved the idea of seeing the opposite,” Shields said. “Cops who are beating people up or white people who are hanging black people—what would they think if it was the other way around? What would the KKK say if this happened to them? It would potentially be the most famous photo of that entire generation.”

After all, the connection between the KKK, who refused to comment on the images, and lynching is heavily engrained in the fabric of its identity in American history.

And that’s what Historical Fiction, which opens May 16 at Andrew Weiss Gallery in Santa Monica, California, is all about: powerful interpretations—and alterations—of impactful moments in history.

“I started thinking about these moments that every generation remembers,” Shields said. “Our generation remembers exactly where they were and what they were doing when 9/11 happened, but I didn’t want to do something so modern.”

Soon he realized that the same applied for the moment JFK was killed, Marilyn Monroe died, or Martin Luther King, Jr. was assassinated. So, he tracked down artifacts (JFK’s toe tag, Marilyn Monroe’s pill bottles and a PanAm plane), vintage clothing and actual newspapers to photograph staged reactions to these now-historical events.

In one image, a row of perfectly primped white suburban housewives sit under massive 60s-style hair dryers reading the daily paper. The front page tells of Marilyn Monroe’s death as shock and horror fills their faces.

For the image inspired by Martin Luther King, Jr., a group of black women mirror the poses of the Monroe image, but their emotions are much more visceral. They look more than stunned as tears stream down their faces; the image no longer looks like a recreation.

Get The Beast In Your Inbox!
By clicking "Subscribe," you agree to have read the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy
Thank You!
You are now subscribed to the Daily Digest and Cheat Sheet. We will not share your email with anyone for any reason

Even in 1976, almost a decade after King was assassinated, his work to bring racial equality was far from finished—chaos was still taking over major cities due to desegregation.

A Pulitzer Prize-winning image by Boston Herald American photographer Stanley Forman captured a white teenager attempting to assault a black lawyer and civil-rights activist during protests against desegregating the city’s buses. His weapon of choice: an American flag.

In The Soiling of Old Glory, it seems as though another white man is holding the arms of Ted Landsmark, the activist, while Joseph Rakes times aim at stabbing Landsmark with the pole.

It immediately became an iconic image, though the facts of the day reveal that the man behind Landsmark was a friend helping him to his feet and Rakes wasn’t spearing the flag, he was swinging it.

Still, “the idea of a student protester using an American flag as a weapon against an unarmed black man, in that city, in that year, was just something absolutely terrifying and horrifying,” Louis Masur, a professor of visual culture at Trinity College, told U.S. News in 2008. “People immediately understood it, and it became a symbol of all the worst kinds of racial hatred imaginable and proof that the civil rights movement of the 1960s hadn’t achieved all its goals.”

Shields has recreated this image with a twist.

In it, a black man holds a white cop wielding a baton back as another black man takes aim with an American flag. It’s not an exact recreation, and the addition of a uniformed cop updates the iconic image into one that could conceivably be seen on the streets today.

The tension between white cops and black suspects has reached an all-time high, most recently visible on the streets of Baltimore.

The murders of numerous blacks, by citizens and police, over the past few years have reignited a long-standing cultural race issue within American society.

The deaths of Trayvon Martin, Michael Brown, Eric Garner and Freddie Gray have sparked riots, and anguished debate.

Another of Shields’ images is of a white cop being pinned down by a group of black men in suits.

“These type of images speaks from the 20s to now,” Shields said. “This could literally be yesterday in Baltimore or Georgia in 1965,” if the black man was the oppressed instead of the white. It could even be the 90s with events surrounding Rodney King. “And there’s just something so powerful about using the American flag as a weapon.”

Shields has never been one to shy away from controversy. Previous works have often sparked public outrage and the occasional death threat.

In 2012, Shields caused uproar for setting fire to a $100,000 alligator skin Hermes “Birkin” bag. And in 2011 domestic abuse groups were furious when he photographed actress Heather Morris bound and sporting a black eye. He calmed both rows by donating money to charity.

He’s been photographing young Hollywood—many of whom are his friends—for years (Emma Roberts, Zachary Quinto, and Lindsay Lohan among others), mostly in death-defying or sexual provocative situations.

But, they’re only a small part of his oeuvre and he’s looking to leave (as one of his show title’s had it) the Dirty Side of Glamour behind to make a name for himself as a high-end artist.

“Celebrity photography is dead. It’s over,” Shields said. Everything is highly airbrushed and if you want an intimate peek into the life of a celebrity, all you have to do is find their Instagram.

Shields, who is originally from Jacksonville, Florida, has no formal training in photography and, instead, started his career as a competitive inline skater (he toured with Tony Hawk) and videographer.

Saturday will be 11 years since he shot his first professional photograph, an empty closet with two pairs of shoes and hanger. An ex-girlfriend who cheated on him with a photographer inspired it. He sold that image at his first show for $75 to a fan from MySpace.

Since then he has created series involving actors and models suspended in air, submerged under water, and in compromising positions.

But he’s spent the past two years focusing on high-end art and getting his works into galleries and museums, as well as publishing books. Last year, he was in a Phillips Auction with iconic photographers Helmut Newton and Irving Penn. Collectors have started to take notice.

Bruce Halpryn, the first person to purchase Shields’s recent lynching photo—long before its gallery debut—also avidly collects Richard Avedon and Herb Ritz. He’s notorious for purchasing soon-to-be iconic images and made a special trip to Los Angeles to see the photo in person. He purchased the print, which is limited to three, it on the spot.

“It has been fascinating to watch Tyler Shields’ photography evolve and mature,” Halpryn said in a statement. “His ‘Lynching’ and ‘American Flag’ are powerful pieces, recalling the civil unrest of the period, but also forcing us to ponder the relationship between the oppressed and the oppressors and how things might have been different.”

As far as the public’s reaction, Shields aim is simple: “I wanted to do something very powerful that asks a lot of questions and start a conversation.”