Who would have guessed that the Oscar-nominated, doe-eyed beauty who broke out in 1988's
would run into such trouble down the road? In 2001, Winona Ryder shocked the world when she was caught trying to make it out of Saks Fifth Avenue in Beverly Hills with more than $5,000 worth of merchandise. The actress was convicted of
grand theft felony and vandalism
, given three years probation, and assigned to 480 hours of community service. In addition, the court ordered Ryder to pay $6,355 in restitution to Saks and to undergo psychological and drug counseling. Six years after the incident, in an interview with
, Ryder claimed she was taking painkillers for a broken elbow that lead her to be in a state of "confusion" at the time of the shoplifting scandal. A year after that interview, in 2008, Ryder allegedly committed jewelry theft again; but reports that she lifted
$124,000 worth of Bulgari jewels
from a Marie Claire photo shoot in Madrid never lead to charges.