0America’s Most Thankful Cities, from Phoenix to PortlandThe Daily Beast calculates the cities that give the most back.The Daily BeastUpdated Jul. 14, 2017 2:39AM EDT / Published Nov. 22, 2012 4:45AM EST 25. Phoenix, AZMatt York / AP Photo 24. Raleigh, NCNick Nicholson / Getty Images 23. New Orleans, LAJonathan Bachman / AP Photo 22. Rochester, NYHunter Martin / Getty Images 21. Minneapolis-St Paul, MNAP Photo 20. Louisville, KYMatt Slocum / AP Photo 19. Charlotte, NCChuck Burton / AP Photo 18. Houston, TXKenny Haner / Getty Images 17. Richmond, VASteve Helber / AP Photo 16. Indianapolis, INMichael Conroy / AP Photo 15. Orlando, FLGetty Images 14. Seattle, WAJim Bryant / AP Photo 13. Tampa, FLChris O'Meara / AP Photo 12. Virginia Beach, VASteve Helber / AP Photo 11. Jacksonville, FLGuido Cozzi / Corbis 10. Dallas, TXWes Thompson / Corbis 9. Oklahoma City, OKJeff Albertson / Corbis 8. Baltimore, MDRichard T. Nowitz / Corbis 7. Portland, ORCraig Tuttle / Corbis 6. Washington, DCCharles Smith / Corbis 5. Atlanta, GABob Krist / Corbis 4. Nashville, TNHenryk Sadura / Corbis 3. Memphis, TNRaymond Gehman / Corbis 2. Birmingham, ALKevin Fleming 1. Salt Lake City, UTRichard Cummins / Corbis The Daily Beast@thedailybeastGot a tip? Send it to The Daily Beast here.
25. Phoenix, AZMatt York / AP Photo 24. Raleigh, NCNick Nicholson / Getty Images 23. New Orleans, LAJonathan Bachman / AP Photo 22. Rochester, NYHunter Martin / Getty Images 21. Minneapolis-St Paul, MNAP Photo 20. Louisville, KYMatt Slocum / AP Photo 19. Charlotte, NCChuck Burton / AP Photo 18. Houston, TXKenny Haner / Getty Images 17. Richmond, VASteve Helber / AP Photo 16. Indianapolis, INMichael Conroy / AP Photo 15. Orlando, FLGetty Images 14. Seattle, WAJim Bryant / AP Photo 13. Tampa, FLChris O'Meara / AP Photo 12. Virginia Beach, VASteve Helber / AP Photo 11. Jacksonville, FLGuido Cozzi / Corbis 10. Dallas, TXWes Thompson / Corbis 9. Oklahoma City, OKJeff Albertson / Corbis 8. Baltimore, MDRichard T. Nowitz / Corbis 7. Portland, ORCraig Tuttle / Corbis 6. Washington, DCCharles Smith / Corbis 5. Atlanta, GABob Krist / Corbis 4. Nashville, TNHenryk Sadura / Corbis 3. Memphis, TNRaymond Gehman / Corbis 2. Birmingham, ALKevin Fleming 1. Salt Lake City, UTRichard Cummins / Corbis