American Idol's eccentric, atonal auditioners make us laugh—and then we never see them again. Richard Rushfield says: pit them against each other in their own show.
Courtesy of FOX
The Pot Stirrer: Tatiana Del Toro, Season 8
Courtesy of FOX
The Icon: William Hung, Season 3
Courtesy of FOX
The Golden Boy: “General” Larry Platt, Season 9
Courtesy of FOX
The Dreamer: Renaldo Lapuz, Season 7
Mark Mainz / AP Images for Fox
James The Natural: James Lewis, Season 7
AmericanIdol.om
The Class Clown: Norman Gentle, Season 8
Frank Micelotta, American Idol / Getty Images for Fox
The Heartbreak Kid: Josiah Lemming, Season 7
AmericanIdol.com
The Ingenue: Mary Roach, Season 4
AmericanIdol.com
Bikini The Bombshell: Katrina “Bikini Girl” Darrell, Season 8
Courtesy of FOX
The Gruff, But Lovable: Steven Thoen, Season 6
The Love God: Martik Manoukian, Season 6
AmericanIdol.com
The Buddy Team: Kenneth Briggs + Jonathan Jayne, Season 6
Frank Micelotta, American Idol / Getty Images for Fox
