Politics

Non-Partisan, but Not Neutral

Entertainment

Binge This

U.S. News

Real Heroes, True Crime

Half Full

Eat. Drink. Think.

Randall Hill/Reuters
RARE

GOP Sen. Tim Scott Sinks Trump Nominee Over Past Racist Writings

The only black Republican senator took issue with Ryan Bounds’ racially charged past writings.

In an extraordinarily rare move on Thursday afternoon, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) withdrew a circuit court judge nomination after Sen. Tim Scott (R-SC) indicated that he would not vote for the nominee, causing other Republican senators to follow suit.

According to a GOP source familiar with the matter, Scott, the only black Republican senator, raised concerns to Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) about Ryan Bounds’ college writings which allegedly included racially charged comments and other controversial statements.

Rubio, the source said, pledged to vote against Bounds alongside Scott, and “more Republicans [were] heading to ‘no’” on the nomination as a result.

McConnell then withdrew the nomination—but not before huddling with his top deputy, Senate Majority Whip John Cornyn (R-TX), in his office off the Senate floor. The saga unfolded just minutes before the scheduled 1:45 p.m. vote. By 2:30 p.m., it was over.

The majority leader’s decision to withdraw the nomination comes as the Republican majority has confirmed a record number of judicial nominees in the first 18 months of Donald Trump’s presidency. Bounds was nominated to serve on the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.

Bounds’ nomination was so toxic that his two home-state senators—Democrats Jeff Merkley and Ron Wyden, who opposed his appointment—tried to use Senate procedures to kill the nomination but were rebuffed by Republicans.

Bounds, who attended Stanford University for his undergraduate studies, was accused of failing to disclosure his writings in The Stanford Review to a bipartisan committee of attorneys that initially recommended him for the post.

During his May confirmation hearing in front of the Senate Judiciary Committee, Bounds apologized for those articles, which he called “overheated, over-broad and too often not as respectful as it should have been of opposing viewpoints.”

“I certainly apologize for the often highhanded and overheated tone I often resorted to in commenting about campus politic,” he told the committee. “The intentions behind those articles were always to seek greater tolerance and mutual understanding on campus—that was always my aim.”

The writings, compiled in a briefing by the Alliance for Justice, tell a different story.

In October 1994, Bounds argued against lowering the burden of proof for students accused of sexual assault.

“There is really nothing inherently wrong with the University failing to punish an alleged rapist—regardless of his guilt—in the absence of adequate certainty, there is nothing the University can do to objectively ensure the rapist does not strike again,” he wrote. “Expelling students is probably not going to contribute a great deal toward a rape victim’s recovery; there is no moral imperative to risk egregious error in doing so.”

Another article in February 1995, took aim at “multiculturalists” who “band together not into tight cliques of mutual interests and complementary powers, but rather into social clubs of ostensibly common racial heritage.”

A third, in October 1994, titled “Lo! A Pestilence Stalks Us,” railed against the “sensitivity” of LGBTQ student reactions to the vandalism of a “gay pride” statue. He also criticized the reactions of Latino students who protested after the lone “high-ranking Chicano” administrator was “terminated.”

“Results: rivers of tears, epithets, hunger strikes, negative press for the university, and the formation of presidential committees to examine the ‘systemic insensitivity’ toward Chicanos at Stanford and the potential for a Stanford-East Palo Alto community outreach center,” he wrote. “Oh, and once again, sensitivity can claim responsibility for extortion, rampant dissatisfaction, and a nice week of hand-wringing.”

Bounds currently serves as an assistant U.S. attorney for the District of Oregon.

Cheat Sheet®

The 10 Most Important Stories Right Now

  1. 1. HMMM

    Nielsen: I ‘Haven’t Seen’ Proof Russia Meddled to Help Trump

    Contradicting the intelligence community’s assessment.

  2. 2. LINES DRAWN

    Russia’s Foreign Affairs Ministry: ‘#FreeMariaButina’

    The agency also changed its Twitter profile picture to an image of Butina.

  3. 3. TWO FACED

    Report: Zuckerberg Called to Congratulate Trump on Election

    For his victory, and a well-marketed campaign.

  4. 4. NEW RULES

    Miami Dolphins to Suspend, Fine Kneeling Players

    Anthem protests are now considered “conduct detrimental to the club.”

  5. 5. GETTING PAPER

    The World Record May Get Broken

    Ad by Orbitz

  6. 6. UH OH

    Report: Three FBI Cybersecurity Officials Are Retiring

    While cyberattacks on the U.S. are on the rise.

  7. 7. UGLY

    Jeanine Pirro: Whoopi Screamed at Me Backstage at ‘The View’

    Following a contentious on-camera interaction with Goldberg, the Fox News host now says their fight continued backstage.

  8. 8. CLOSED DOORS

    Sexual-Assault Support Group Was Hijacked by Trolls: Report

    “Facebook doesn’t seem to understand that their tools are the bread and butter of manipulators.”

  9. 9. WONDER WHY

    Trump’s Intel Director Won’t Deny He’s Considered Resigning

    There are “days when you think, ‘ugh, what am I doing,’” he said.

  10. 10. ALL GROWN UP

    Robin in New ‘Titans’ Trailer: ‘F*ck Batman’

    The series takes a darker look at the “Teen Titans” comic book and animated TV show.