Entertainment

Binge This

Half Full

Eat. Drink. Think.

Politics

Non-Partisan, but Not Neutral

REUTERS/Joshua Roberts
COUNTERPUNCH

Democrats Shred Devin Nunes’ Surveillance Memo

The memo is in response to one declassified by President Trump alleging surveillance abuses by the FBI.

Scott Bixby2.24.18 5:00 PM ET

Two weeks after President Donald Trump blocked its release on national security grounds, the House Intelligence Committee on Saturday released a 10-page memo intended to counter Republican claims that the FBI acted inappropriately in pursuing a warrant to surveil former Trump campaign aide Carter Page.

The memo, penned in January by Rep. Adam Schiff, the committee’s ranking Democrat, was released with redactions on Saturday afternoon after weeks of negotiations between the committee and the Justice Department over what material would be released to the public. Trump had said earlier this month that the unredacted memo “contains numerous properly classified and especially sensitive passages.”

Schiff’s memo was written to counter a four-page Republican memo, written by Rep. Devin Nunes, which alleged that the FBI’s decision to include allegations made in a dossier prepared by British ex-spy Christopher Steele in a FISA warrant application called into question the “legitimacy and legality of certain [Justice Department] and FBI interactions with the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court.”

The Justice Department had argued against that memo’s declassification, citing “grave concerns about material omissions of fact that fundamentally impact the memo’s accuracy.”

Moments after he was fêted as a conquering hero at the Conservative Political Action Conference, the memo’s release on Saturday was a body blow to his credibility as a government watchdog. The Schiff-authored memo undermines many of the claims made in Nunes’ document. Among them, the memo declares that Steele’s intelligence reporting “did not inform the FBI’s decision to initiate its counterintelligence investigation,” and that the special counsel investigation into Page’s potential links to the Russian government were based on “troubling” information unrelated to the dossier.

Schiff’s memo also appears to undercut Nunes’ argument that the FBI had hidden the fact that Steele’s had been backed by Trump’s political opponents from the FISA court.

“Far from ‘omitting’ material facts about Steele,” the memo states, “DOJ repeatedly informed the Court about Steele’s background, credibility, and potential bias.” The Department of Justice, the memo alleges, explained Steele’s financial relationship with those who had “likely political motivations” behind the dossier, and that the FBI still had reason to find Steele credible on matters relating to Russia.

The memo states that “senior FBI and DOJ officials have repeatedly affirmed to the Committee the reliability and credibility of Steele’s reporting,” and called the process to vet his allegations—including those against Page—as “rigorous.”

Nune’s memo had also claimed that the FISA materials “relied heavily” on news articles based on leaks from Steele himself, an allegation that Schiff’s memo undercuts. “DOJ referenced [the] article,” the memo states, “not to provide separate corroboration for Steele’s reporting, but instead to inform the Court of Page’s public denial of his suspected meetings in Moscow.”

In a statement, Schiff said that the release of his memo “should put to rest any concerns that the American people might have as to the conduct of the FBI, the Justice Department and the FISC.” His review, he said, “failed to uncover any evidence of illegal, unethical, or unprofessional behavior by law enforcement and instead revealed that both the FBI and DOJ made extensive showings to justify all four requests.” 

In a statement to The Daily Beast, the White House labelled the Schiff memo an attempt to “undercut the President politically,” but noted that Trump still supported its release.

“This politically driven document fails to answer serious concerns raised by the Majority’s memorandum about the use of partisan opposition research from one candidate, loaded with uncorroborated allegations, as a basis to ask a court to approve surveillance of a former associate of another candidate, at the height of a presidential campaign,” said White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders. “As the President has long stated, neither he nor his campaign ever colluded with a foreign power during the 2016 election, and nothing in today’s memo counters that fact.”

The president had declared the release of Nunes’ memo “vindicated” his denials of any contact or collusion with the Kremlin during the 2016 presidential campaign—although multiple Republican members of the House Intelligence Committee didn’t see it that way.

“I actually don’t think it has any impact on the Russia probe,” Rep. Trey Gowdy (R-S.C.) said on CBS’ Face the Nation at the time. “There is a Russia investigation without a dossier... The dossier has nothing to do with the meeting at Trump Tower. It also doesn’t have anything to do with obstruction of justice, so there’s going to be a Russia probe with or without the dossier.”

Nunes disputed Gowdy’s assertions at the time—and the newest memo’s assertions upon its release.

“The American people now clearly understand that the FBI used political dirt paid for by the Democratic Party to spy on an American citizen from the Republican Party,” Nunes said in a statement. “It defies belief that the Department of Justice and FBI failed to provide information to a secret court that they had provided to an open federal court regarding their past interactions with Mr. Page.”

Cheat Sheet®

The 10 Most Important Stories Right Now

  1. 1. OUTRAGEOUS

    Ex-RNC Chair Steele Slams ‘Painfully Stupid’ CPAC Remark

    The communications director for the conservative gathering reportedly told guests Steele was elected RNC chairman “because he was a black guy.”

  2. 2. WINDFALL

    Warren Buffett: Tax Law ‘Delivered’ $29B Gain to Berkshire

    The boost “did not come from anything we accomplished at Berkshire,” the billionaire tells shareholders.

  3. 3. ABANDON SHIP

    Delta, United Airlines End Discounts for NRA Members

    “We will be requesting that the NRA remove our information from their website.”

  4. 4. WAR

    UN Security Council Votes Unanimously for Syria Ceasefire

    After more than 500 civilians were killed in a matter of days.

  5. 5. Smart

    These 5 Bags Will Change The Way You Travel

    Ad by Daily Beast Shop

  6. 6. MISSED OPPORTUNITY

    Several Cops Accused of Waiting Outside During FL Shooting

    Police officers say deputy Scot Peterson was not the only one who failed to enter the high school.

  7. 7. LOST AND FOUND

    Stolen Degas Painting Found on Bus Near Paris Rest Stop

    Nearly a decade after the $1 million painting was taken by unknown thieves.

  8. 8. ‘HOLY COW’

    U.S. Men’s Curling Team Wins First Olympic Gold Ever

    After beating No.1-ranked Sweden to pull off an unexpected victory.

  9. 9. SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT

    CNN Releases ‘Doctored Email’ From Shooting Survivor’s Dad

    After the family accused the network of using scripted questions at a town hall event on gun control following Florida’s deadly shooting.

  10. 10. DEVIL AT THE DOOR

    Vatican Sets Up Exorcism Training Courses Amid High Demand

    A Sicilian priest and trained exorcist says exorcism requests have tripled in recent years.