ANDY UNCENSORED

Andy Cohen Admits to Having a ‘Bad’ Sex Tape With Broadway Actor

The Bravo exec shocked his “Watch What Happens Live” audience with his admission of the tape’s existence.

Andy Cohen has admitted that he has a sex tape with his ex-boyfriend, former Broadway actor and producer John Hill. Cohen made the admission on Tuesday’s episode of Watch What Happens Live as Hill listed off the “top five things” Cohen should do in 2025. Among the things on Hill’s list included seeing Cohen “get tits,” “learn how to read,” and release their tape “from 2003.” Cohen laughed at the thought while his guests, model Racquel Chevremont and housewife Erika Jayne, remained shocked. Yet thankfully, according to Cohen, it’s not easily accessible. “The format, it’s on some janky format,” he said, when asked where it can be seen. According to Hill, “It’s bad.” Cohen, 56, and Hill, 46, dated for nearly three years before they went their separate ways. According to Hill, he headed to Hollywood looking for a career change, and Cohen stayed behind, moving up the ranks at Bravo. “It was heartbreaking and super sad,” said Cohen about the split on the “Hot Takes and Deep Dives” podcast. “But like any breakup … it was time to break up.”