Skip to main content
SCHOOLED

MAGA Rep Publicly Humiliated as Crowd Laughs in His Face

The congressman was told to “calm down” after rising from his seat in a huff.

A MAGA congressman was publicly humiliated when his Democratic challenger turned one of his signature re-election campaign boasts against him.

Rep. Mike Lawler, a New York Republican who has touted his work on the state and local property tax deduction, or SALT cap, had a tense exchange with Democrat Cait Conley at a candidate forum on Thursday.

The SALT cap, which limits federal deductions for state and local taxes, became a flashpoint in Trump’s tax-and-spending bill. Lawler cast a decisive vote for the package, but critics say its deep healthcare cuts hurt his voters.

Cait Conley

Cait Conley is challenging Lawler to represent New York’s 17th Congressional District.

Spencer Platt/Getty Images

Lawler himself seemed visibly triggered when called out over the SALT cap.

A clip of the confrontation shared by the X account TrumpsTaxes racked up more than 130,000 views. The footage showed Lawler rising from his seat before the forum moderator told him to sit down and “calm down.”

During the exchange, Lawler said Hudson Valley residents had received a $4,000 tax refund “in your pocket this past April.”

“And that would have also happened if you did nothing,” Conley immediately shot back.

“No it wouldn’t have,” Lawler fumed, drawing laughter from the crowd.

“Oh wow,” the account piled on. “Mike Lawler got so rattled when Cait Conley accurately called him out on his SALT deduction lie that he tried to get up and leave before being told by the forum moderator to sit down and calm down. Oh, and the crowd laughed at him, too.”

Conley, who is seeking to unseat the two-term Republican in New York’s 17th Congressional District, also attacked him on X on Thursday.

“Trump created the SALT deduction cap in 2017 to punish New York,” she wrote. “It was set to expire ENTIRELY at the end of 2025, but Mike Lawler voted to make it a permanent tax on working families to fund tax breaks for billionaires.”

She added that the cap would return to $10,000 in 2030, “when Mike is running for his next office.”

“Trying to spin this as a win is an insult to the Hudson Valley,” she wrote. “We deserve better.”

Mike Lawler speaks to a crowd

Lawler has touted his work on the state and local property tax deduction, or SALT cap.

Eduardo Munoz/REUTERS

Lawler fired back on Thursday, defending his record and accusing Conley of supporting a massive tax hike.

“I fought to quadruple the SALT cap which let over 90% of Hudson Valley households deduct their state and local taxes,” he wrote.

He claimed Conley’s position would increase Americans’ taxes by $4 trillion and cost families in his district an additional $5,000 that year. He also claimed the standard deduction would have been cut in half, the child tax credit rolled back, and tax rates increased.

“Cait Conley wants to go to Washington to raise your taxes, plain and simple,” he wrote.

During a September appearance on CNN’s State of the Union, Lawler pointed to the SALT negotiations as proof of his ability to get results under presidents of either party.

“When Joe Biden was president, I was able to get things done. When Donald Trump is president, I’m able to get things done,” Lawler said.

“I have been able to bring back tens of millions of dollars to my district, and I delivered one of the biggest wins for New York by standing up to President Trump on the issue of SALT,” he added.

The Daily Beast has reached out to representatives for Lawler and Conley for comment.

Sign in or create an account

Login dialog

Loading comments…

TRENDING NOW