Trump’s Favorite Cardinal Dresses Him Down for AI Pope Stunt
Timothy Dolan insisted the president still “takes his Christian faith seriously” as critics slammed the social media gag.

Franco Origlia/Getty Images
President Donald Trump‘s second-favorite pick for the papacy has slammed the president for a social media stunt decried by critics as “tasteless” and “deeply offensive” to Catholics.
“Well, you know, it wasn’t good,” New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan told a team of reporters ahead of a Sunday Mass in Rome, where next week he will be participating in the conclave to elect a new Holy Father following Pope Francis’ death three weeks ago.
He then said: “brutta figura,” an Italian colloquialism that is used when someone embarrasses themselves.
Dolan comments added to the discourse around the AI image Trump and White House social media accounts posted late Friday that depicted the president as pope with a large crucifix around his neck.
Responding to general questions before Mass at his titular church this morning in Rome, Cardinal Dolan spoke about President Trump‘s post on social media dressed as a pope. @thegnewsroom pic.twitter.com/sF1zshVTP3
— Mary Shovlain (@maryshovlain) May 4, 2025
While Trump has in recent days spoken openly about his support for Dolan potentially assuming the papacy, he’s also increasingly joked about having his own papal ambitions. Trump quipped to reporters that he was his own “No. 1 choice” to succeed Francis.
ADVERTISEMENT
Dolan said he believes the Trump still “takes his Christian faith seriously” and he hopes Trump “didn’t have anything to do with” the AI-generated image, which has even sparked backlash from pro-MAGA voices. One conservative X account warned, “you’re going to lose a lot of Catholic support over stunts like this.”
The New York Cardinal joins other high-ranking U.S. members of the Catholic Church condemning the gag—among them Illinois Bishop Thomas Paprocki, who wrote in a statement on X that “this is deeply offensive to Catholics[,] especially during this sacred time that we are still mourning the death of Pope Francis.”
Get the best of The Beast delivered right to your inbox
By clicking “SUBSCRIBE” you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Paprocki added, “[Trump] owes an apology.”
Senior members of the GOP have nevertheless rallied around the president. Vice President JD Vance, himself a practicing Catholic, wrote on X that “as a general rule, I’m fine with people telling jokes” in response to the controversy.
Sen. Lindsey Graham, who earlier this week called for cardinals at next week’s enclave to “keep an open mind” about Trump’s non-existent pontifical prospects, also joked on Saturday the image was “worth a thousand words” and MAGAists should listen out for “more updates to come.”
However, Trump as pope wasn’t the only White House AI flub to have caused a stir this week. The Pentagon landed in hot water on X after posting a bonkers picture of Pete Hegseth at the southern border. In the photo, he appears to be fending off a trio of nefarious-looking men holding an ever-so-subtly labelled box of “DRUGS.”
The Defense Secretary’s pinky finger was also missing from the image, which included an American flag conspicuously short 18 of its 50 stars and one of 13 stripes.
The photo fail comes on the heels of intensifying scrutiny over Hegseth’s fitness for the job amid several Signalgate scandals.
“Even if you ignore the missing finger, this image makes Hegseth look like he’s the bodyguard for Scary Drugs Men,” wrote one X commentator about the image.
Even if you ignore the missing finger, this image makes Hegseth look like he’s the bodyguard for Scary Drugs Men. https://t.co/SLss1Kac1a
— @red3blog (@red3blog) May 3, 2025
Register below to read this article for free or subscribe
to unlock unlimited access to The Daily Beast.
Monthly
$1
First month then $5.99/month
Annual
$35
First year then $59.99/year
Premium
$79
First year then $119.99/year
*Substack access provided by the next business day, using your subscription email. Choosing the Premium plan constitutes your permission to share your subscription email with Substack and your agreement to Substack’s Privacy Policy.
Already have an account? Sign In
Looks like you already have a subscription!
You're all set!
Thanks for subscribing.




