Skip to main content
GREAT SCOTT!

Surprise Favorites Emerge to Replace Fired MAGA Mouthpiece

A former pageant queen, a CNN pundit, and even Laura Loomer are among the names bettors are backing.

Incoming White House Press Secretary Katie Zacharia holds her first press briefing at the White House in Washington, DC, US, October 13, 2026. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque

Kevin Lamarque/REUTERS

Favorites to replace Katie Zacharia, President Donald Trump’s short-lived MAGA mouthpiece, are emerging.

Anna Kelly, a former beauty pageant winner who served as deputy press secretary under both Karoline Leavitt and Zacharia, whose tenure lasted just five days, is an early favorite to land the gig, according to Kalshi.

anna Kelly

Anna Kelly, left, was the deputy to former White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt.

Anna Kelly/X

The prediction market gave Kelly, a 29-year-old redhead, a 25 percent chance of becoming the next face of the Trump White House, succeeding a trio of blondes that stretches back to Kayleigh McEnany at the end of Trump’s first term.

Kelly was followed by CNN’s token MAGA pundit, Scott Jennings, who had a 20 percent chance as of early Friday afternoon on Kalshi.

The early favorites to succeed Katie Zacharia as press secretary.

The early favorites to succeed Katie Zacharia as press secretary.

Kalshi

Next in the rankings were MAGA 1.0 deputy press secretary Hogan Gidley, 50, at 16 percent; podcast host Katie Miller, 35, at 12 percent; former Trump communications aide Harrison Fields, 31, at nine percent; former RNC spokeswoman Danielle Alvarez, 37, at eight percent; and U.S. chief of protocol Monica Crowley, 58, also at eight percent.

The betting comes in the immediate aftermath of Trump, 80, pulling the plug on Zacharia after she fled her first press briefing following just three softball questions, her law credentials were exposed as a farce, and she made a bumbling appearance on Sean Hannity’s show.

Play Video

Far-right provocateur Laura Loomer, who traveled with the president on Air Force One as recently as this month, has pitched herself for the job, writing on X, “Hear me out: Press Secretary Laura Loomer.”

The 33-year-old was given a three percent chance on Kalshi, which is offering odds for a laundry list of 52 names, plus the option of “no new press secretary.”

JOINT BASE ANDREWS, MARYLAND - OCTOBER 02: Political activist Laura Loomer follows behind U.S. President Donald Trump as he walks off Air Force One on October 02, 2026 in Joint Base Andrews, Maryland. Trump travelled to Mobile, Alabama for a campaign rally. (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

Laura Loomer has her own idea of who she'd like to see as White House press secretary.

Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images

Other long-shot possibilities include the potential return of Leavitt, now a contributor at Fox News, and McEnany, who hosts her own show on the network.

The list also includes the president’s Fox News host daughter-in-law, Lara Trump, and recently ousted Fox News host Maria Bartiromo. Rounding out the long shots are Fox and Friends co-host (and wife of Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy) Rachel Campos-Duffy; one-time Trump lawyer Alina Habba; newly hired assistant White House Press Secretary Beni Rae Harmony; and even Charlie Kirk’s widow, Erika Kirk.

Sign in or create an account

Login dialog

Loading comments…

TRENDING NOW