Skip to main content
Literary Gotham

Writers to New York: I Wish I Knew How to Quit You

If Sari Botton’s first anthology was all about why writers leave New York, her second one dwells on the artists who stay.

articles/2014/12/01/writers-to-new-york-i-wish-i-knew-how-to-quit-you/141130-hannon-new-york-tease_nsjkle

Sari Botton

In E.B. White’s essay Here is New York, he said that there were three kinds of New Yorkers, the last being the dreamers, who were responsible for what he called the ‘third city’: “It is this third city that accounts for New York’s high-strung disposition, its poetical deportment, its dedication to the arts, and its incomparable achievements.” Almost a hundred years later, White’s third city, or his idea of it, still endures— attracting dreamers both ambitious and creative.

Writer and former New Yorker Sari Botton loosely addressed White’s idea of the third city and its artsy dreamers in her anthology Goodbye to All That. 28 stories, by 28 women, discussed the ideals that “third city” dwellers place on the New York, the series of the highs and lows, and the realizations that inevitably follow. They discussed what it means to be a writer—a volatile profession to begin with, especially in a city that can be either inspiring or depressing—and how this made one eventully leave.

TRENDING NOW