Blogs and Stories

Stanley Crouch

Obama Vs. Farrakhan

Barack Obama What explains Obama's success? A new generation of Americans that was finally able to see a man as distinct from his race.

In a book for which I have only to write the last section, assessing all that has happened over these final months of a continually startling contest, I look into the deeper cultural underpinnings of Barack Obama's extraordinary appeal. The book begins with the great distraction that Obama has prevailed through and which, if the country was still as it used to be, would have made his run impossible. The event was the nadir of black nationalism put on nationwide display at the 1995 Million Man March in Washington, D.C. Many black men were gathered at the behest of Louis Farrakhan, the clown prince of despotism.

Farrakhan was and remains in a photo finish with David Duke and all other sanctimonious button-down primitives. They are part of our collective fate, there to prove to us that no group is invulnerable to the persuations paranoia, fake science, potted history, nor the megalomania of charismatic men. Thirty-two years after the March on Washington at which Martin Luther King expressed a timeless optimism about the human possibilities of our country, Farrakhan and his hundreds of thousands seemed proof that black America had completely torn its ass in public and set all thoughts of forward motion at a standstill. The civil rights establishment had finally submitted to—and been swallowed by—the dirty cartoon of demagoguery, which celebrated itself through Farrakhan with a loud belch.

By the time Obama ran, black Americans proved themselves what the Civil Rights Movement had always claimed: We can be just as good or just as bad as you. We are only human.

Faced with such a daunting spectacle, what did Barack Obama do? What made it possible for him to have shaken the nation awake to its actual transcendent identity when he won the Iowa Primary in January? So much focus on the range of black Americans, especially in our news media, has provided substantial proof that the black community is as susceptible to mediocrity as any other. Obama knew what to make of that. That is very important.

During the Civil Rights movement and in the writings of men like James Baldwin, there was the idea that the "black experience" bestowed something more soulful, earthy, and transcendent on that ethnic group and that was the thing that could save America. When one looks only at the violent decadence, mindless misogny and compulsive crude materialism of hip hop it is easy to see that no ethnic version of American culture is automatically able to sustain the sort of vitality necessary to replenish it. Right now the country has been forced to face something else about human behavior at least partially because of men like Farrakhan, the high profile fradulence of the Tawana Brawley hoax, Jesse Jackson's philandering and imprenating a mistress during the time that he prayed with Bill Clinton. We cannot forget the noxious behavior of certain black athletes and entertainers. In short, black Americans proved themselves what the clearest thinkers of the Civil Rights Movement had always claimed: We can be just as good or just as bad as you. We are only human.

With that wind of human reality strongly behind him, Obama suddenly appeared like a fresh light in the sky on a very dark night. With what some came to eventually dismiss as the technique of a masterful inspirational speaker, he used to captivate his audiences with the lyricism of his patriotic American feelings and his great theme that we are all in this together and will rise or fall as one people. He made it seem inarguable that every grand achievement in our nation is connected to every other one and they from a heritage in which we all share. That was the way that Obama renewed patriotism and took it from the jaws of the Republicans who dipped it in too much sentimentality. Patriotism in Obama's rhetoric ceased to seem corny because it embraced all of the social tragedies the country had overcome over two centuries. It opened the way to a vision of democracy in which no one, no group, no type was left out. This was imperative and he made it seem real. The people loved it and turned out in droves to hear him reiterate what they perhaps had not believed since childhood in public school.

Back to Top
November 1, 2008 | 9:54am
Facebook
|
Twitter
|
Digg
|
|
Emails
|
print
Comments ()

psomniferum

This is an excellent and insightful essay. Thoroughly enjoyed reading this one Mr. Crouch.

|
|
Reply
2:30 pm, Nov 1, 2008

sangsue

I think that's actually what racists hate about him. He doesn't fit into their stereotype, he's educated with good family values so he threatens them.

|
|
Reply
3:47 pm, Nov 1, 2008

easmachine

I like Obama and have already voted for him. I also appreciate Farrakhan, flaws and all. There is a reason that the white power structure demands that all black men denounce/condemn Farrakhan before reluctantly bestowing its grudging acceptance upon him. No other man in America is so reviled. Not Klan Leaders. Not White Supremacists. Not Anti-Semites. Not Charles Manson or the Unabomber. Though
there is no evidence that he has lifted a finger to harm anyone.
I have no problem with the pride that some of us have in our heritage of survival and overcoming obstacles in a land that condemned us to chattel status. Has he not heard the racists shouting "kill the nigger" at Palin rallies? The socialist/communist tag that Miss Alaska second runner up puts on Obama reminds me of the same tags that the racists put on Martin Luther King and many other black leaders. Come on Crouch. Without Farrakhan, there would be no Obama 08. If there had been no example of Farrakhan' and the NOI's rejection of America, there would be nothing to appreciate about Obama's embrace of it.

|
|
Reply
7:31 pm, Nov 1, 2008

CarvelQ

Nice piece.

|
|
Reply
9:18 pm, Nov 1, 2008

Yankintex

Madonna put-down aside, I agree with everything Crouch says. A point I'd like to add: it's easier to accept the fresh breeze of Barack Obama and forget the stench of men like Farrakhan after more than a decade of hate-filled rhetoric from the far-right. Their extremism -- and America's rejection of it and divisive politics generally, regardless of "color" or origin -- has actually gone a long way toward producing the wonderful time we're now experiencing. Sweet, isn't it.

|
|
Reply
8:05 am, Nov 2, 2008

Teuthida

Both my parents, lifelong Republicans in their 70's, voted for Obama. When I asked my mother why, she said "I like Obama. He's not a black politician, He's an inspiring politician who happens to be black."

It warmed my heart to think we as a nation have come this far. I see great things ahead for us with Obama sa President.

|
|
Reply
8:16 am, Nov 2, 2008

msilverstein

I loved seeing Mr. Crouch on Ms. Brown's late lamented TV show and I love his comments. Mr. Crouch is someone with something to say and I applaud his appearance here. Unfortunately the same can not be said of Ms. Brown's chosing Laura Bennett from Project Runway. Everyone need not be serious but Ms. Bennett has nothing to say and is not very likable. Infact on Project Runway she was negative and mean.

|
|
Reply
10:06 am, Nov 2, 2008

barrybar

This is as elegant a piece by Mr. Crouch that I have read. I respect his strong voice and his take-no-prisoner approach, but totally disagree with him for condemning people like Louis Farrakhan and Rev. Wright who choose to speak out in righteous indignation. Which it is easier to do when you are not running for office.

Mr. Crouch's attacks against people whom he finds distasteful is no less rabid than the "truth" spoken by so many who are ashamed of what America has done in race relations and war. He writes his truths and they speak theirs. So many ways to get from here to there.

|
|
Reply
4:18 pm, Nov 2, 2008

LardGreystoke

This progression has some implications for the future. The old-time racists are simply dying off. Four years from now there will be that many fewer bigots for Miss Sarah to pander to, and that many fewer viewers for Faux News.

Not to rule out that the younger generation won't come up with their own version of idiocy, but it's nice to see the narrow-minded America I grew up in slowly fade away.

|
|
Reply
1:39 am, Nov 3, 2008

magrifin

You have explain so well the transformative value of Barack Obama and this election. I can't wait to see your book.

|
|
Reply
1:29 pm, Nov 3, 2008

coloradocrazy

Perhaps all of you should really listen to Obama and the rhetoric of the left, both of the Democrats and the media. There has been nothing but racial inuendos coming from the Obama camp, not outright, but in a suggestive way. The media on the other hand, has practically called everyone not voting for Obama racist! I am not voting for Obama because I don't agree with his ideas, not skin color. It is an insult to suggest that people who are not voting for Obama are racist, but that is what you put out there. Making assumptions about others and placing labels should be beneath every American, regardless of race! Maybe it is time for Obama and the left to put away the race card and just run on ideas!

|
|
Reply
3:58 pm, Nov 3, 2008

LMuhammad

I have learned over the years that there are various writers or scribes that use their forums to write disparaging remarks about men that they purposely misunderstand do to envy and jealousy. I appreciate your insight on our beloved brother Obama, however your irrational and uneducated comments about Farrakhan shows that you need to do some more research, about a holy and righteous man that has sacrificed more than fifty years of his life to see our people go free. I understand that some of us love to do the will of our enemies that are totally against our liberation as a people. Be careful in an hour like this, because we all will reap what we sow and it is better to learn and study a man for yourself. Then to let others define that man to you, remember no man in history has ever called a Million Man March and nearly two million men showed up. Also, 85% of the people at the march were Christians, so ask yourself why would God use a so called racist according to you to bring into existence such a monumental event. May God bless you with the light of understanding, but your disposition on the Honorable Louis Farrakhan proves that he is the Divine Servant of God in our midst.

|
|
Reply
9:30 am, Nov 8, 2008

knowitallnation

It's clear to me by your analysis of others that you missed the spirit of what Barack Obama has done in setting a standard for moral excellence and service to all Americans. To state that over one-million men who showed-up on the mall in the spirit of a generation's work to better themselsves was in fact an anal tear is disgusting, reprehensible, and disturbing. It makes me suspect that you too are one the wrong side of real CHANGE.

|
|
Reply
12:28 pm, Nov 11, 2008

ljackson

I found this piece to be offensive. Whatever it is that you hate about Minister Farrakhan he is nowhere near responsible for creating the negative realities that is the condition of Black People in America than America herself. Minister Farrakhan Himself has expressed pride and appreciation for the brilliance and accomplishment of Barak Obama. As the new president Mr. Obama will no doubt swear in with his hand placed over the Holy Bible. The well known parable of the good samaritan contained in that bible has to do with a man who needs help. That man has been attacked and robbed and lays along side the road bleeding and unable to help himself. In my own "personally inspired translation" I can see Stanley Crouch walking by on the opposite side of the road and pointing his finger in condemnation of this poor soul who needs help. So I Imagine you hate Minister Farrakhan because He is trying to help or get help. There is something to be looked at in putting both Minister Farrakhan and Barak Obama in the spotlight together. But it aint nothin like the way you spin it. There is much that they agree on whether you like it or not. I think well reasoned people should look much deeper than Stanley Crouches so called "deeper look"

|
|
Reply
4:23 pm, Nov 11, 2008

L4muhammad

Dear Mr. Crouch,
First of all, God is a Man, and to see what The Honorable Minister Louis Farrakhan has been doing and still is doing for, not only Blacks, but for the entire human family of the planet earth is proof that he is a man that is backed by the God of Righteousness, The Lord of The Worlds.That God is the same God that you and I and everyone else who claim the God of Righteousness serves.
I ask you Mr. Crouch to Please look deeper into the man that you speak of in an ill manner. He is a Divinely guided man, and reguardless of what you may think or how you may feel, The Million Man March was absolutley a sign given to us and the world from God himself. It brought blackmen together to atone with each other, and to atone with God Himself. Go back and watch that event and see what actually took place that day and make sure you listen closely to Minister Farrakhan's speech and see and hear for yourself if he taught hate or division, or if what he spoke to those nearly 2,000,000 (two million) Blackmen was a message that inspired and encouraged Us to be better men and clean up our neighborhoods. He encouraged Us to join a church, a jewish temple, a mosque, The Nation of Islam, or some type of organization that would help raise up righteousness in our communities. There were gangs that came together on that day and signed peace agreements and embraced each other with love on that day. PLEASE go back Mr. Crouch and see it for yourself and write the truth about this man called Farrakhan.
I pray, Mr. Crouch, that Allah (God) allows you to really see the man that you speak so incorrectly about. Because if Minister Farrakhan is indeed the one that God is using in this day and time, then not only is this article displeasing to me and all who have heard Farrakhan and love Farrakhan, but most importantly it would be displeasing to God Himself.
Thank you Mr. Crouch for reading my comment and I sincerely hope and pray that look through scripture and see how the messengers and warners of God were mistreated and spoken against by the very people that they were sent to save from the chastisement of God. And what happen to the few people who sided with those men of God, and what ultimately happen to those who followed the enemies of God and began to try and lead the people away from the one who was from God. Study for yourself Mr. Crouch. Get Minister Farrakhan's lectures yourself, logg on to www.finalcall.com watch Minister Farrakhan live via webcast. He recently spoke about our President elect Barack Obama 11/09/2008. Take a look at that lecture and if you would please write an article on it and tell us what were your thoughts. Again, thank you Mr. Crouch, and know that I am praying that you will see that Farrakhan is your brother and that he needs your help and your talent to bring about a Universal peace among the human family.
As-Salaam Alaikum (Peace be unto you)
Linton Muhammad

|
|
Reply
10:52 am, Nov 13, 2008
Leave a comment

Thank you.
As a first time user, your comment has been submitted for review. It can take anywhere from a few hours to a day or two for your comment to be reviewed, depending on the time of week and the volume of comments we receive.

View Comments

Obama Vs. Farrakhan

by Stanley Crouch

Info
RSS
Stanley Crouch
Emails
|
print
Single Page
|
text
-
+
Facebook
 | 
Twitter
 | 
Digg
 |