Blogs and Stories
Dear President Obama, Save My Father's Train Station...
Bebeto Matthews/AP
If Obama wants to stimulate the economy by spending $700 billion on great public works projects, he can start with New York's Moynihan Station.
When my father, Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan, passed away in March 2003, I vowed that I would deliver his final gift to the city he so loved: one billion dollars to rebuild New York's Penn Station, the largest transportation hub in the United States, fittingly known as The Pit.
Moynihan Station had everything the city needed most: 50,000 new jobs, a means to steer the metropolitan region towards energy sanity, a chance to avenge the destruction of the late great Penn Station and reverse the decline of government commitment to public works.
If there is a regional Green Energy public works project more substantive than Moynihan Station, show me the plans.
Five years have passed. No jackhammers or hard hats fill The Pit. But now, amid the ruins of hedge funds and derivatives, the cyclic collapse of Happy Free Marketeers, I hope that Moynihan Station can rise at last. With a new president committed to building great projects to get the economy moving again and a new U.S. senator from New York to succeed our new secretary of state, Hillary Clinton, few things should make more sense than that they become champions of Moynihan Station.
It's unhealthy to spend too much time browsing Internet sites about the old Penn Station, but I can't help it. So much was lost in October 1963, when the wrecking ball crashed into Charles McKim's masterpiece. A public space of magisterial grandeur that uplifted and united all citizens who once passed through Doric columns, lingered beneath a dome modeled on the Baths of Caracalla. Now we lurch through a squalid mall squeezed under the Knicks’ locker room, praying that the train is on time so we can escape the indignity of The Pit.
No citizen is obliged to read a bad book or watch a bad movie. But no one can escape the degrading assault of a bad building, especially a public building. Ramble through The Pit's lowly basement corridor if you can stand it, where a feast of toxic victuals are arrayed, Krispy Kreme and Dunkin’ Donuts, where anxious hordes roam past black and white photos of the old Penn Station, tacked on the wall, seemingly in jest.
Senator Moynihan once wrote: "Architecture is inescapably a public art, and conveys to future generations the political values of a certain age." Our grandparents lived in the Golden Age of public works, our parents saw those monuments destroyed, while we loiter through a sterile mall. What does the grim, joyless Pit say about our political values? Yes, Penn Station was destroyed by a city that claims to value art and beauty, by the bankers who support the opera as they tear up the city's monuments and homesteads, pilfering land and money.
In May 1999, redemption appeared, as President Clinton and Senator Moynihan held a press conference before The Pit and handed the new project, funded and approved, to the city elders. But Mayor Rudy Giuliani boycotted the ceremony and denigrated the station to the press. The administration of Governor George Pataki had 12 years to put a shovel in the ground, but nothing happened beyond a steady stream of meetings and press conferences, which cost the state an estimated $300 million.
I frequently asked why the city and state refused to spend anything for a Moynihan Station public education campaign, when an estimated $80 million was spent on New York's 2012 Olympic bid. I had hopes that making the Global Warming/Green Energy case would arouse enthusiasm, but there has been no effort to promote the station as a green project. If there is a regional Green Energy public works project more substantive than Moynihan Station, show me the plans.







teaparty
Maura - that was a great article. I have never understood why public transportation rarely gets on the table as a alternative even though it reduces tons of carbon emissions. And the wasted funds you mentioned...we ought to be outraged and show our representatives that wasting our taxes is intolerable. This is urgent but does anyone move on it! It just feels like our politicians have no respect for the public who they are supposed to represent. Here in Boston our transit authority raised parking charges at rail stations by 50%!!! Fares were raised a couple of years ago by 30% and are rumored to go up again next year. They mismanage, we pay. Yet they keep their jobs and keep the huge salaries. I'm disgusted - Deval Patrick's platform was all about green alternatives but obviously now that he's been elected that's gone by the board.
PeteInAstoria
Maura,
Moving the wretched Pit to the beautiful Farley Post Office would not just honor your father's legacy but will also go back to the beginnings of NYC's preservation movement, spearheaded by Jackie Kennedy when the original Penn Station was demolished. Moving Penn Station into the proposed Moynihan Station would absolve our city's original mass transit sin. Along with the under-construction Fulton Street Transit Center, Moynihan Station will serve as the beginning of a new era of transportation in New York. However, the rest of the city's mass transit needs cannot be ignored. The Second Avenue Subway needs to be constructed. Our stations need to be renovated. The MTA must be saved, and congestion pricing just might be the answer.
Thank you for continuing your father's service to our state and our city, but please don't forget that transit goes beyond midtown.
Iamadog
Oh, how I wish everyone would read this and rally, but alas, it will fall to the bottom of a list to long to read. Not only Penn Station, but also a commitment to passenger rail to go along with it. What a wonderful world it would be! Fat chance, but I'm happy to see the article. Thanks.
Thank you.
As a first time user, your comment has been submitted for review. It can take anywhere from a few hours to a day or two for your comment to be reviewed, depending on the time of week and the volume of comments we receive.