Blogs and Stories

Max  Blumenthal

How I Got Gassed in the West Bank

BS Top - Blumenthal Gaza Gas Fadi Arouri / Reuters While Barack Obama met with Benjamin Netanyahu, Max Blumenthal was dodging tear-gas canisters in the West Bank, where a two-state solution seems very, very far away. WATCH THE VIDEO.

When Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met Barack Obama at the White House on Monday, he warned the president that time was running out to stop a nuclear Iran. By impressing upon Obama the immediacy of the threat from Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Netanyahu hoped to avoid committing to the two-state solution he and his right-wing governing partners have so far openly and forcefully opposed. While Netanyahu attempts to recalibrate the discussion toward Iran, his government continues a vast expansion of the occupation of the West Bank, creating “facts on the ground” to fulfill the vision of a Greater Israel.

Click Below To View Video

Watch Part Two Below

The recognition by the U.S. and the West of a viable Palestinian state in partnership with Israel has never seemed more like a pipe dream. After spending a week on the West Bank, I observed that settlement of the West Bank is being consolidated and expanded. Armed resistance by Palestinian groups lies dormant, while those Palestinians who employ nonviolent means to resist the Israeli government’s plan to divide and annex their land are being met with draconian and sometimes lethal force.

The small Palestinian village called Ni’lin is located just miles outside Israel’s 1967 Green Line, directly in the planned path of the separation wall. Israel’s winding concrete and fence barrier would permanently sever Ni’lin from much of its farmland, effectively annexing the land to several Jewish settlements that surround the village. In May 2008, Ni’lin’s local governing committee declared a popular struggle against the wall, organizing weekly marches and actions to block the path of its construction. While factional divisions between Fatah and Hamas rivet most of the Occupied Territories, the struggle in Ni’lin is one of factional unity against dispossession.

International activists and a small band of Israelis who, after serving jail sentences for refusing to serve in the army, also rushed to Ni’lin, hoping that their presence would mitigate the army’s violence against local Palestinians.

Confronting a fusillade of tear gas, rubber bullets, and live ammo with protest signs and the occasional slingshot, the people of Ni’lin and their allies have so far managed to halt the wall. But their momentary success has come with a heavy price; since May, the Israeli army has killed four young villagers and critically wounded an American activist, Tristan Anderson, with a self-propelled tear-gas shell that hit him in the head.

I arrived in Ni’lin on the 61st anniversary of “Nakbah Day,” or what Palestinians call “the catastrophe.” Joining me was Jesse Rosenfeld, a 24-year-old Jewish-Canadian journalist who has lived on the West Bank and in Israel since 2007. Jesse is one of the few reporters to have covered Ni’lin’s struggle since its inception. He led me up a narrow street toward a crowd of demonstrators attempting to march to the wall. A phalanx of Israeli soldiers flanked on opposing hillsides by heavily armed troops blocked their path. The confrontation grew increasingly antagonistic when a man angrily displayed to the Israeli unit commander a photograph of Ahmed Mousa, a 10-year-old boy shot in the head and killed by Israeli forces when he attempted to remove barbed wire from the separation wall. “You killed him!” the man shouted. “You are responsible for his death!”

With that, the soldiers fired a salvo of tear-gas shells and percussion grenades at the crowd, sending everyone sprinting downhill. As I ran, tear-gas shells landed all around me. By the time I reached the town center, my eyes seared with pain and I struggled to breathe. “This is nothing,” Jesse remarked to me. “This is just soldiers having fun.”

Back to Top
May 21, 2009 | 5:57am
Comments ()
sonofloud

Israel is completely out of control and disregards international law at a whim, with cover provided by the United States.

|
|
Reply
|
9:21 am, May 21, 2009
nothyslf

Why does nobody speak of the many UN violations by Isreal?

|
|
Reply
1:33 pm, May 21, 2009
thepiedpiper

I'm not sure if you'd like empathy or sympathy for getting gassed, but you're not getting either from me.
I can not empathize with the situation because Israel truly is held to a ridiculous double-standard when it comes to their national security. Israels' measures are completely reactionary, and are the direct result of palestinian behavior.
I can't sympathize with this because thats what happens when you taunt and attack people with guns. Sorry dude.

|
|
Reply
10:28 am, May 21, 2009
Banjo1

Continueing to burnish his credentials with the left, Max discovers to his surprise that the Israelis play hardball.

|
|
Reply
|
11:13 am, May 21, 2009
nothyslf

It really is amazing that whenever the truth about Isreal's actions are exposed to the world there are are people like you that seem to justify their disgraceful behavior as "hardball" They are killing people and uproooting them from their home to create lies on the ground to justify their right to exist. It really is pathatic and in my mind, no different than the ideology of any religous extermist. Oh wait! the holucust..I forget that makes all of Isrealis actions ok? Isreal will eventually destroy herself by the lies and decit she has plagued the world with. the IDF are an accepted terriost organization supported by America and the the Christian fanatical right that live in America.

|
|
Reply
1:10 pm, May 21, 2009
Maverick

I love it when playing hardball involves clubbing farmers in the head, firing into crowds, and violating international law. By these standards, Chris Matthews can go quite a bit farther if he wants to live up to his show's mantra.

|
|
Reply
|
1:59 pm, May 21, 2009
jackee

What Chris Matthews does on TV IS an atrocity already, Maverick. I would suggest we send him to the War Crimes Tribunal in the Hague. If his show is picked up on satellite TV, I bet we can charge him with a violation of "international law" too!

|
5:23 pm, May 21, 2009
isr1214

Boy, talk about one sided journalism. Why was the wall built - because Israeli citizens were being killed by terrorist bombers. Has the wall stopped the killing - you bet. Did Israel want to build the wall - no way. Why are their refugee camps - because the oil rich Arab countries who sponge up trillions of our dollars do nothing about it. They would rather leave their "brothers"' to fester in squalor as long as it serves their political agenda. Every other refugee group has been taken care of, There 's no reason for refugee camps in the West Bank except that no one wants to help. By the way, there is a Palestinian State; in fact there are two. The original British Mandate, that was supposed to a Jewish homeland, was divided into two pieces - 75% went to create the state of Trans-Jordan that was to be the Palestinian homeland (that no Jew was allowed to enter) and 25% was left for the Jewish homeland. Then in 1947, the UN took the 25% and split it again into a Jewish and Palestinian homeland. Three-fourths of the land Israel got was desert, but they took it. The Arabs refused partition and started the war to drive the Jews into the sea. Now the world wants a third partition - do you think that will bring peace? The Arabs refuse to recognize Israel. When Gaza was given back to Hamas, did they build an economy to help their people? No, they turned it into an armed camp to rain bombs down on Israeli citizens. THEY are completely out of control, Israel is just responding in order to survive.

|
|
Reply
11:22 am, May 21, 2009
archiwt

The U.S. pushes democracy everywhere but Israel

|
|
Reply
11:53 am, May 21, 2009
Bartholomew

So what happened to the "John Hagee Ministries" swimming pool area, of which a drawing appears here?:

http://go.ariel.muni.il/ariel/en/index.php?option=com_content&task=view& id=169&Itemid=1

Does it exist or is there just that piece of laminated A4 stuck to a wall?

|
|
Reply
12:29 pm, May 21, 2009
sfsmurf

Israel is a rogue state that must be contained.

|
|
Reply
12:39 pm, May 21, 2009

This comment has been removed by The Daily Beast's editors.

|
|
Reply
2:56 pm, May 21, 2009
SCMax101

It is awful that some Palestinian land must be sectioned off for the creation of the protection wall, but the fact is that it has reduced bombings and other terrorism to such an extent that it would be awful not to continue construction.

It is a tragedy when those Palestinian children died but I don't think there is an army on earth where the soldiers would not shoot when they are being approached by a mob with rocks.

|
|
Reply
|
5:55 pm, May 21, 2009
DevilsLawyer

Awful but, tragedy but. Do Palestinian property rights and, you know, life, count for you at all?

|
|
Reply
|
7:26 am, May 23, 2009
Happydancer

And since when is the life of a Palestinian more precious than the life of an Israeli? SCMax101 is right. The Partition Wall is a necessity in order to continue protecting Israelis from Palestinian terrorists.

|
1:04 am, May 24, 2009
whoelse

Another tragedy was Auschwitz. Another one occurred in Rwanda. And Darfur. Now that is a tragedy too. I am really really tired of tragedies. They just keep happening because some people always think they are entitled to have what others have since they know they are better or that God meant them to have everything they want. So stop with the talk of people throwing rocks. Israelis throw bullets and bombs.

|
|
Reply
12:00 pm, Jun 2, 2009
muddog

Wow, shooting kids with rocks in their hands, now there's a fair fight!!. And we wonder why the Arab world hates us and attacks with Suicide bombs.

I am no fan of Hesbola or Hammas but it does not takeb rocket sceince to figure out why so many of the Arab world feel helpless and resort to such extreems.

Funny how the spoiled American public just does not understand how a dirt poor Arab in Palastine is so determined to rid the west bank of Jews....



|
|
Reply
7:04 pm, May 21, 2009
VinceP1974

oh boo hoo, the barbarians dont have the upper hand yet.... oh poor them.... poor poor poor barbarians.

The only way to comprehend the behavior of the Palestinians is to understand what the Treaty of Hudaybiyya is. That is where the word Hudna comes from.

A hudna is a "temporary treaty" which can be approved or abrogated by Islamic religious leaders, depending on whether or not it serves the interests of Islam, and that a "hudna" cannot last for more than ten years. A hudna is a ploy in Islamic warfare whereby a false peace is declared during which the muslim side rebuilds for war and once they feel ready, they will violate the treaty and resume the war..

Arafat was criticized for signing the Oslo Accord with Israel, in respsonse to the critics Arafat said "I see this agreement as being no more than the agreement signed between our Prophet Muhammad and the Quraysh in Mecca.". That is the Treaty i mentioned above.

Arafat was telling the truth, because the PA did nothing but prepare the Arabs for war throughout the 1990s and in 2000 he began his war against Israel.

Until the arabs disavow the concept of Hudna, only a fool would trust them

|
|
Reply
|
7:59 pm, May 21, 2009
DevilsLawyer

Barbarians? Pssst... Your racism is showing.

|
|
Reply
7:27 am, May 23, 2009
putzflek

It's very easy to come to a place, know very little about it, and assume you understand what you're seeing. There's more than meets the eye here, besides the fact that the Arabs are experts in utilizing gullible lefties to their needs (fabricating some facts, manipulating others).
Having said that, the Ni'ilin matter is a disgrace for Israel. Sadly, most Israelis are oblivious to the story (can't really blame them: after years of terror attacks they easily accept the explanation that it's for "security reasons").

You know, it's kinda funny how you used the term "shocking". Oh how brave indeed of you, Blumenthal, to stand in the line of Israeli "live ammo". you're just so clueless it's just sad.

ps - go to Afghanistan. there you'd see what harsh treatment is. I dare you, oh brave one.

|
|
Reply
8:08 pm, May 21, 2009
putzflek

muddog,
o sancta simplicita!
if it were only that simple. Keep blaming the Arabs for what "we are doing", and continue disregarding their refusal to join the rest of us in the 21st century. I guess you regard them as the noble savages, eh?

|
|
Reply
8:14 pm, May 21, 2009
Leave a Comment
Leave a comment

Thank you.
As a first time user, your comment has been submitted for review. It can take anywhere from a few hours to a day or two for your comment to be reviewed, depending on the time of week and the volume of comments we receive.

View Comments
Leave a comment

Please log in to leave comments.

How I Got Gassed in the West Bank

by Max Blumenthal

Info
RSS
Max  Blumenthal
Emails
|
print
Single Page
|
text
-
+
Facebook
 | 
Twitter
 | 
Digg
 |