The logo for the Daily Beast's Obsessed website. It reads: 'Obsessed: What to Watch, Binge, See, & Skip'
DAILY BEAST
Membership call to action crossword iconCrosswordNewsletters
  • Cheat Sheet
  • Obsessed
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Entertainment
  • Media
  • Innovation
  • Opinion
  • Reality TV
  • U.S. News
  • Scouted
CHEAT SHEET
    POLITICS
    • Biden World
    • Elections
    • Opinion
    • National Security
    • Congress
    • Pay Dirt
    • The New Abnormal
    • Trumpland
    MEDIA
    • Confider
    • Daytime Talk
    • Late-Night
    • Fox News
    U.S. NEWS
    • Identities
    • Crime
    • Race
    • LGBT
    • Extremism
    • Coronavirus
    WORLD
    • Russia
    • Europe
    • China
    • Middle East
    INNOVATION
    • Science
    TRAVEL
      ENTERTAINMENT
      • TV
      • Movies
      • Music
      • Comedy
      • Sports
      • Sex
      • TDB's Obsessed
      • Awards Shows
      • The Last Laugh
      CULTURE
      • Power Trip
      • Fashion
      • Books
      • Royalist
      TECH
      • Disinformation
      SCOUTED
      • Clothing
      • Technology
      • Beauty
      • Home
      • Pets
      • Kitchen
      • Fitness
      • I'm Looking For
      BEST PICKS
      • Best VPNs
      • Best Gaming PCs
      • Best Air Fryers
      COUPONS
      • Vistaprint Coupons
      • Ulta Coupons
      • Office Depot Coupons
      • Adidas Promo Codes
      • Walmart Promo Codes
      • H&M Coupons
      • Spanx Promo Codes
      • StubHub Promo Codes
      Products
      NewslettersPodcastsCrosswordsSubscription
      FOLLOW US
      GOT A TIP?

      SEARCH

      HOMEPAGE
      0

      The Tortuous History Of The Greta Berlin Tweet Controversy

      Another Update

      Ali Gharib

      Ali Gharib

      Updated Apr. 21, 2017 3:15PM EDT / Published Oct. 07, 2012 4:19PM EDT 

      After Free Gaza Movement co-founder Greta Berlin tweeted a clearly anti-Semitic movie, the group made brief comments saying that the video was not intended to be disseminated publicly, and had been posted to a private Facebook group "discussing propaganda and racism." In the statement, Berlin seemed to apologize only for the fact that the tweet had gone public. That clearly wasn't enough, and we had our frequent contributor Emily Hauser write up the tweet. She wrote an eloquent post, covering the Free Gaza statement and denouncing the way anti-Semitism hurts both Jews and the Palestinian cause.

      The Berlin story broke on Monday, and Emily's post had given the activists days to offer a more full explanation, with none forthcoming. Then shortly after we published, Berlin came out with a broader personal statement denying that she was a Holocaust denier and arguing that she’d posted the video because it embodied the kind of “propaganda that our group was discussing." Since Emily's post was pegged to the Berlin's non-apology, we all agreed that it would be best to write an update. In that update, Emily noted Berlin's troubling history—linking to Berlin's glowing endorsement of Gilad Atzmon—and said Berlin should release the full context of the discussion on private Facebook group. Choosing to keep her focus where it had always been, on the content of the tweet itself, Emily wrote, “I am sorry that in writing about a real problem, I used Greta Berlin as the example around which my thesis was built.” Blogging is, of course, a fast-paced enterprise, and sometimes you react to news even as it’s developing.

      Circumstances have again changed. The prominent pro-Palestinian activist and writer Ali Abunimah, who had led the charge to condemn Berlin's tweet (pending exculpatory hard evidence), chased down an instance of the same anti-Semitic video being posted to a private Facebook group that Berlin administers. On his blog at the Electronic Intifada, he wrote:

      When the video was posted [by another user] on 28 September it was neither preceded nor followed by any interactions that would fit the description that it “was shared with a group of people who were discussing propaganda and racism, and this link was an example of the terrible propaganda that could be spewed on websites.” This context does not exist.

      Emily took to her own blog this morning, linking to Abunimah's post and explaining why she'd updated her first post: because, as best as we could tell at that moment, the Berlin's more full explanation rendered the thrust of Emily's first post "absolutely inaccurate." Emily added that she regrets using the qualifier of "absolutely" (which we should have caught on the editing end).

      Abunimah's reporting cast doubt on Berlin's version of events. But now Berlin tells +972's Larry Derfner that Abunimah doesn't have the right Facebook group, producing a statement from some 16 members of the purportedly correct group backing up Berlin's account, and deflecting charges on other accounts of tweets and writings. (I find some of her statements, including explaining the Atzmon endorsement, unconvincing.) Abunimah hasn't yet reacted to the Derfner story. On twitter, others are seeking verification about the purported signatories of the statements.

      No matter how private Berlin's Facebook group, with nearly half its membership outed, she should release screenshots of the original context of the video posting. The privacy of the discussion was compromised when Berlin, if her version of events is on the level, linked her Facebook to Twitter and accidentally posted an anti-Semitic video to Free Gaza's twitter account. Releasing a reliable rendering of the Facebook discussion would put this to rest. The onus is on Berlin.

      Ali Gharib

      Ali Gharib

      @https://twitter.com/Ali_Gharib

      Got a tip? Send it to The Daily Beast here.

      READ THIS LIST

      DAILY BEAST
      • Cheat Sheet
      • Politics
      • Entertainment
      • Media
      • World
      • Innovation
      • U.S. News
      • Scouted
      • Travel
      • Subscription
      • Crossword
      • Newsletters
      • Podcasts
      • About
      • Contact
      • Tips
      • Jobs
      • Advertise
      • Help
      • Privacy
      • Code of Ethics & Standards
      • Diversity
      • Terms & Conditions
      • Copyright & Trademark
      • Sitemap
      • Best Picks
      • Coupons
      • Coupons:
      • Dick's Sporting Goods Coupons
      • HP Coupon Codes
      • Chewy Promo Codes
      • Nordstrom Rack Coupons
      • NordVPN Coupons
      • JCPenny Coupons
      • Nordstrom Coupons
      • Samsung Promo Coupons
      • Home Depot Coupons
      • Hotwire Promo Codes
      • eBay Coupons
      • Ashley Furniture Promo Codes
      © 2023 The Daily Beast Company LLC