Taylor Kitsch, alas, is on the verge of himbodom. Coming off a stellar run as hunky football player Tim Riggins on NBC’s Friday Night Lights, his potential star power seemed almost unlimited. But his first big play at Hollywood leading man material, after a supporting X-Men role, struck out hard. Kitsch played the buff, tanned, loin-cloth-sporting lead in the Disney sci-fi adventure flick John Carter, all elements that should have cemented his leading man status. But the movie tanked, losing Disney almost $200 million. Kitsch’s second strike, the big budget board game-turned-action flick Battleship, costarring Liam Neeson and pop star Rihanna, also flopped. With big-name stars, extensive CGI, ships blowing up, and Brooklyn Decker’s bosom, Battleship should have had all the ingredients for Hollywood summer success, but it hit a low $25.5 million domestic bow. We’re hoping Savages, the drug-dealer flick Kitsch has cued up for this summer, doesn’t seal his place on our list.