By Linda Qiu, Jon Greenberg, and C. Eugene Emery
One of the main topics on the Sunday shows this week was Donald Trump’s admission that President Obama was born in the United States.
But in acknowledging that Obama was born in the United States, “period,” Trump repeated a false attack Friday that it was Hillary Clinton who was behind the conspiracy theory. His surrogates repeated that claim on Sunday. The claims are wrong.
“Hillary Clinton and her campaign of 2008 started the birther controversy,” Trump told reporters at the tail end of a press event in Washington. “I finished it.”
That’s False. There is no evidence that Clinton or her 2008 campaign floated the theory, nor is it accurate for Trump to say he finished the controversy. While some Clinton supporters circulated the allegations in 2008, neither the candidate nor her staff ever discussed the issue publicly.
Clinton conceded the race on June 7, 2008, and three days later a website called Pumaparty.com encouraged Clinton backers to support Republican nominee Sen. John McCain.
The website promoted the theory with an email that read, “Obama May Be Illegal to Be Elected President,” as Daily Beast editor John Avlon has documented.
According to Avlon, Linda Starr, a Clinton volunteer in Texas, was key to spreading the rumor. She connected with Philip Berger, an attorney and Clinton supporter, who sued to block Obama’s nomination. The suit was thrown out.
In the case of the email, there is no evidence Clinton or her campaign played any part. No connection between Starr, Berger, and the Clinton campaign ever emerged, as much of the story started after Clinton already suspended her campaign.
And about that part Friday where Trump said, “I finished it.” The statement rates Pants on Fire. In no credible sense is this true. Trump didn’t “finish” fanning the flames of birther conspiracies once Obama released his long-form birth certificate in April 2011—he kept tweeting about it for at least another 3½ years. And a core group of Americans hasn’t “finished” expressing birther sentiments. As recently as a year ago, various polls have found that 13 percent of Americans supported the viewpoint.
Another topic from the shows: Young voters carried Obama to victory in the past two elections and felt the Bern for Bernie Sanders during the 2016 Democratic primary. But polls show they’re not exactly transferring their enthusiasm to Clinton.
The 69.2 million millennials—typically defined as adults under age 35—now make up the second-largest age block in America after the baby boomers. While Clinton still leads Donald Trump among young voters, polls show sizable portions of millennials now backing the Libertarian Party’s Gary Johnson and the Green Party’s Jill Stein. (In comparison, third party candidates received about 3 percent of the vote in 2012.)
Clinton’s trouble connecting with millennials prompted NBC’s Chuck Todd on Meet the Press to ask Clinton’s running mate, Virginia Sen. Tim Kaine, how the campaign could rebuild the Obama coalition and win swing states without them. Kaine agreed that that young voters are crucial and laid out “five litmus test issues” that should convince them to get with her.
“Do you believe in climate science or don’t you? Millennials do, Hillary Clinton and I do, Donald Trump doesn’t. Do you believe women should be able to make their own health-care decisions, or don’t you? Millennials do, Hillary Clinton and I do, Donald Trump doesn’t. Do you believe in immigration reform or don’t you? We do, millennials do, Donald Trump doesn’t. Do you believe in LGBTQ equality? We do, millennials do, Donald Trump doesn’t. And finally, do you have a plan to deal with college affordability? We have one. Millennials need one. And Donald Trump, with Trump University, has ripped off students,” Kaine said.
Does Clinton have more in common with the youth than Trump on the five issues Kaine laid out?
We asked the Clinton campaign and Trump campaigns for data showing how millennials feel about the various issues. We didn’t hear back from the Trump side. A Clinton spokesman sent us a report that surveyed millennials in only 11 swing states. In addition, it used questions phrased to favor Democratic talking points, such as asking about “making the wealthy pay their fair share” and “implementing common sense gun safety rules.”
We will not be using those results. But the campaign later sent us other polling data.
In addition, we did our own search. Here’s what we found.
Kaine’s assertion on climate change is largely accurate. A 2014 Gallup survey found that 58 percent of 18- to 29-year-olds believe global warming’s effects have already begun.
A national poll conducted in 2015 by Harvard’s Institute of Politics found that 55 percent of 18- to 29-year-olds agreed with the scientific consensus that the planet is warming and emissions “from cars and industry facilities” are to blame. But 20 percent said that, although the planet is warming, natural changes in the environment are to blame, which is at odds with the consensus of the experts. Twenty-three percent believe global warming is a “theory that has not yet been proven.”
Clinton has called for more pollution controls, investing more in clean energy and cutting “wasteful” tax subsidies for oil and gas companies.
And as we reported in June, during a May 26 energy policy speech Trump advocated rescinding “all the job-destroying Obama executive actions, including the Climate Action Plan” and said he would “cancel the Paris Climate Agreement and stop all payments of U.S. tax dollars to U.N. global warming programs.”
Women’s health care
Kaine said women should be able to make their own health-care decisions. Few people would disagree that women—or men, for that matter—should be able to make their own health-care decisions. In a political context, Kaine’s comments indicate Clinton’s position in favor of abortion rights.
A 2014 poll by the nonpartisan organization PRRI (formerly the Public Religion Research Institute) in Washington found that 55 percent of millennials thought abortion should be legal in most or all cases. The same level of support is seen in people under 68. Only older Americans showed less support for abortion, with 43 percent of people over 67 saying it should be legal.
Similarly, when Gallup surveyed abortion attitudes in 2015, it found that 53 percent of people age 18 to 34 identified themselves as “pro choice,” versus 52 percent of 35- to 55-year-olds and 47 percent of people over 55.
Once again, that puts millennials in the Democratic camp, but not by an overwhelming amount.
Clinton spokesman Josh Schwerin subsequently directed us to a Fox News survey taken last week that found 61 percent of registered voters under age 35 reported being pro-choice.
Clinton, as with most Democrats, supports the right of a woman to seek an abortion. Trump doesn’t address abortion on his website, but he’s said in interviews that he opposes abortion in most cases. In a March interview, he said women who have an abortion after it’s outlawed should received “some form of punishment,” but he backtracked on the idea after widespread criticism.
Once again, the Clinton-Kaine team seems to be in sync with at least a bare majority of millennials.
Immigration is another issue where the stances of Trump and Clinton diverge dramatically.
Trump has made the removal of undocumented immigrants his signature issue. He wants to build a wall across the southern border and change the law that dictates that if you are born in the United States you automatically become a U.S. citizen.
Clinton, in contrast, has called for legislation to allow some of those living in the United States illegally to remain, especially young adults brought to the United States as children. Most—criminals are a major exception—would be eligible for an eventual path to citizenship.
On the issue of the wall, millennials are firmly against Trump. According to a 2016 PRRI survey, 70 percent oppose it, compared to 52 percent of people age 65 and older.
Only 11 percent of Americans age 18 to 29 support identifying and deporting illegal immigrants (it’s 23 percent for people age 65 and older), according to a 2015 PRRI poll; and 69 percent of younger voters support a path to citizenship, as do 58 percent of seniors.
More recently, a Fox News poll taken in last August found that 87 percent of respondents under 35 favored setting up a system for illegal immigrants to become legal. Only 11 percent supported deporting as many as possible.
Also, Trump seems to be out of step with the younger people in his own party, 63 percent of whom support a path to citizenship and just 20 percent of whom want mass deportation.
Polls show millennials overwhelmingly support gay rights, which is a plank of Clinton’s platform. But Kaine is exaggerating when he suggests Trump is totally against LGBT equality—the Republican nominee has given mixed messages on the issue.
An August GenForward survey, conducted by the Black Youth Project at the University of Chicago and the AP-NORC Center, found that young voters (defined as age 18 to 30) strongly supported LGBT individual rights including equal employment rights (90 percent), HIV/AIDS prevention and treatment (92 percent) and LGBT adoption (80 percent).
According to a May 2016 Pew report, 71 percent of Americans born after 1981 favor same-sex marriage (as do 55 percent of all Americans).
Clinton’s LGBT promises mirror the attitudes of millennials in the GenForward survey. She calls the Supreme Court ruling that legalized gay marriage in 2015 as a “landmark victory” for the country.
Kaine, for his part, signed an executive order that banned discrimination based on sexual orientation in Virginia in 2006, his first year as governor. Equality Virginia, the commonwealth’s LGBT organization, called him a friend and major ally in an editorial to The Advocate.
Trump, meanwhile, has vowed that he “will do everything in my power to protect LGBT citizens” in his speech at the Republican National Convention. He often criticizes the Clinton Foundation for taking donations from governments that oppress gay men and women.
But Trump opposes gay marriage and has said in interviews during the Republican primary that he would appoint judges that would reverse the Supreme Court ruling or allow states to decide.
The Human Rights Campaign, a gay rights groups that endorsed Clinton, points out that Trump’s running mate, Indiana Gov. Mike Pence, passed a 2015 law that allowed businesses to refuse to serve gay and lesbian customers based on religious freedom; the law was modified after an uproar.
Trump isn’t against making colleges more affordable, but polls show millennial attitudes on higher education costs are more closely aligned with Clinton’s than Trump’s.
Many millennials say college affordability is a top issue, according to a USA Today/Rock the Vote survey, and the vast majority say higher education should be debt free (77 percent in a poll commissioned by Bankrate Inc., a financial services company).
Under Clinton’s college affordability plan—retooled with input from Sanders in June 2016 and seen as a grab for his millennial voters—families with incomes less than $85,000 will pay no tuition at in-state public colleges and universities, with the income cap increasing to $125,000 by 2021. Clinton’s plan also addresses student debt refinancing.
Kaine focused on complaints lodged against Trump University in his Meet the Press interview. We found that Trump University received a D-minus rating from the Better Business Bureau in 2010, the last time the consumer watchdogs gave any rating at all.
Trump has been vague about his own college affordability plans. In an Iowa town hall in November 2015, he suggested he would create “some governmental program” to help lower-income families pay for school. He promised to “work with all of our students who are drowning in debt” during the Republican National Convention.
His website does not list college affordability as an issue, but Trump policy adviser Sam Clovis floated a few ideas in a May interview with Inside Higher Ed.
Clovis said the campaign thinks student loans should be “market driven” and said colleges should “have skin in the game,” and share the risks associated with student loans. Clovis rejected proposals for free higher public education.
Read the full fact-checks at PunditFact.com.