WITH US OR AGAINST US

Poll Reveals Most Americans Think the Nation’s Divisions Can’t Be Overcome

Voters named polarization and democracy as their most pressing concerns.

Americans are losing faith in the great experiment.

A new poll released Thursday reveals that most Americans believe the country is too far gone to overcome its deep divisions. Just a third of voters think the United States is still capable of solving its political problems, according to the survey from Siena University and The New York Times.

These responses stand in stark contrast to those from September 2020, when 51 percent of voters still believed Americans could unite to address their challenges—even in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. Now, in September 2025, that number has dropped to a harrowing 33 percent.

“It is impossible now to have a policy discussion,” Amber Yang, 37, of Boston, told the Times. “There’s no consensus on the facts,” she added. “And when you can’t have a conversation, how do you even move forward?”

More than half of Americans—55 percent—still see the country as a democracy, according to the poll. But a growing portion—41 percent—disagreed.

These results reflect the country’s deepening polarization, which few voters cited as a top concern until recently. Last October, less than one percent of voters named polarization and division as important issues ahead of the presidential election, surveys show.

Today, the majority of the 1,313 registered voters polled named polarization and the state of democracy as their most pressing concerns outside of the economy, outranking immigration, inflation, crime and more.

The poll was conducted between Sept. 22 and 27, according to the Times, following the high-profile assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk at a Utah university.

RUTHLESS SCHEME

How Trump Is Turning Kirk Tragedy Into Power Grab: Guru

Erkki Forster

His killing was the catalyst for President Donald Trump and his acolytes to declare war on “the left,” turning tragedy into a political weapon.

It also follows a string of political violence and threats this year, including the arson attack on Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro’s residence, the murder of a Democratic state lawmaker in Virginia, the gunning down of a UnitedHealthcare executive, and more.

Trump himself narrowly survived an assassination attempt in July 2024, when a bullet grazed his ear during a rally in Butler, Pennsylvania.

The ripple effects of such events are clear: in April 2024, a PBS NewsHour/NPR/Marist poll showed that a fifth of U.S. adults believed Americans might have to resort to violence to get the country back on track.

A year later, that number had jumped to 30 percent, NPR reported.

Still, most Americans don’t—or at least don’t want to—see each other as enemies. The Times reported that just 10 percent of Democrats polled categorized Republicans as the enemy, a modest decline from 2024.

About 14 percent of Republicans named their political opponents as adversaries.

“Stuff has gotten out of hand,” Al Heymann, a Trump supporter from Louisiana, told the Times.

“It’s just pulling sides apart when we really need to come together to make things happen. But neither side wants to do that.”

See more of our coverage in your search results.

ADD THE DAILY BEAST ON GOOGLE

Laura EspositoBreaking News Reporter

Got a tip? Send it to The Daily Beast here.