SCOTUS Justice Refuses to Recuse Himself Over ‘Conflict of Interest’
Justice Samuel Alito has been accused of “undermining public confidence in the impartiality of the court.”
Get The Swamp newsletter delivered straight to your inbox
By clicking “SIGN UP” you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Conservative Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito has rebuffed calls to recuse himself from a major looming decision.
A coalition of liberal groups asked the Senate Judiciary Committee to look into Alito’s involvement in the case, which involves energy companies ExxonMobil and Suncor Energy as they look to throw out a Colorado lawsuit seeking damages for harms related to climate change. The left-leaning groups cite Alito’s stock holdings in energy companies as the reason he should recuse himself.
But Alito, 76, is ignoring these calls, with a court spokesperson saying, “Alito does not have a financial interest in any party” involved in the case, and that his counsel has advised that “his recusal is not required.”
Alito has dismissed calls for his recusal.
Vincenzo Livieri/REUTERS
While Alito, a George W. Bush appointee, does not own stock in ExxonMobil or Suncor Energy, he did hold stock in oil companies ConocoPhillips and Phillips 66, as well as several other energy firms, according to his most recent financial disclosure report, which was filed last year.
The liberal groups have accused Alito of “undermining public confidence in the impartiality of the court.”
“His irregular recusal practice in oil and gas industry-related cases is undermining public confidence in the impartiality of the Court. They could not occur were he compelled to adhere to enforceable ethics standards against adjudicating cases where he has financial interests or the appearance of a conflict of interest where his impartiality might reasonably be questioned,” the groups wrote.
The landmark climate case will be heard later this year.
Chip Somodevilla/via REUTERS
Under Supreme Court ethics guidelines, justices do not have to recuse themselves from cases unless they have a direct conflict of interest, like stock ownership or a personal relationship with one of the parties.
But the letter sent by the liberal groups argues that justices should still rescue themselves if their “impartiality might reasonably be questioned” by an “unbiased and reasonable person who is aware of all relevant circumstances.”
The high court is expected to hear arguments in the case during its next term, which starts in October.
Unlock a year of full access to The Daily Beast for $35.
Monthly
$1
First month then $5.99/month
Annual
$35
First year then $59.99/year
Premium
$79
First year then $119.99/year
*Substack access provided by the next business day, using your subscription email. Choosing the Premium plan constitutes your permission to share your subscription email with Substack and your agreement to Substack’s Privacy Policy.
Looks like you already have a subscription!
- Account (completed)
- Payment (completed)
- Confirmation (completed)
You're all set!
Thanks for subscribing.
- 1Account
- 2Payment
- 3Confirmation
Sign in or create an account
Register below to read this article for free or subscribe
to unlock unlimited access to The Daily Beast.
Monthly
$1
First month then $5.99/month
Annual
$35
First year then $59.99/year
Premium
$79
First year then $119.99/year
*Substack access provided by the next business day, using your subscription email. Choosing the Premium plan constitutes your permission to share your subscription email with Substack and your agreement to Substack’s Privacy Policy.
Already have an account? Sign In
Looks like you already have a subscription!
- Account (completed)
- Payment (completed)
- Confirmation (completed)
You're all set!
Thanks for subscribing.
- 1Account
- 2Payment
- 3Confirmation

Sign in or create an account
Login dialog
Loading comments…