
The overwhelming majority of soon-to-be college students indicate that they head to college to guarantee higher earnings in the future. To find out which schools are worst at offering a well-paid future for relatively less tuition, The Daily Beast first limited the universe of schools to only those that graduate at least 75% of students within six years. Our thinking: a degree is not valuable if you don’t get it, and schools that don’t have a good track record of graduating students aren’t offering a reliable return on a student’s investment regardless of cost or potential future earnings. We then calculated a net price based on the percent of students who graduate within four, five, and six years to create an average net price for all students who graduated within six years; this figure was worth a third of the final ranking. The last two-thirds of the ranking was devoted to starting and mid-career salary of graduates, according to Payscale.com.

Oberlin, Ohio
6-Year Grad Rate: 88%
Average Net Price: $34,797
Average Starting Salary: $38,800
Average Midcareer Salary: $83,900
Scott Shaw/The Plain Dealer /Landov
Notre Dame, Indiana
6-Year Grad Rate: 78.8%
Average Net Price: $26,391
Average Starting Salary: $41,100
Average Midcareer Salary: $62,200
*Correction: This slide previously incorrectly showed an image of Mount St. Mary's College in Los Angeles. The image has been updated to reflect the correct college. We apologize for the error.

Poughkeepsie, New York
6-Year Grad Rate: 80.3%
Average Net Price: $31,073
Average Starting Salary: $43,000
Average Midcareer Salary: $71,700

Kalamazoo, Michigan
6-Year Grad Rate: 79.6%
Average Net Price: $26,347
Average Starting Salary: $36,300
Average Midcareer Salary: $75,000
Lumigraphics/Getty
Upland, Indiana
6-Year Grad Rate: 80.4%
Average Net Price: $24,392
Average Starting Salary: $38,000
Average Midcareer Salary: $70,500
AJ Mast/AP
Bloomington, Illinois
6-Year Grad Rate: 82.5%
Average Net Price: $27,134
Average Starting Salary: $39,400
Average Midcareer Salary: $74,400
Nick Burchell
Elon, North Carolina
6-Year Grad Rate: 82.1%
Average Net Price: $28,208
Average Starting Salary: $43,200
Average Midcareer Salary: $69,100
Sara D. Davis/AP
Wooster, Ohio
6-Year Grad Rate: 75%
Average Net Price: $23,668
Average Starting Salary: $41,800
Average Midcareer Salary: $64,000

South Hadley, Massachusetts
6-Year Grad Rate: 84.9%
Average Net Price: $23,910
Average Starting Salary: $39,400
Average Midcareer Salary: $69,400
Dave Roback/The Republican /Landov
Norton, Massachusetts
6-Year Grad Rate: 77.1%
Average Net Price: 27,451
Average Starting Salary: $37,300
Average Midcareer Salary: $82,500
Stephan Savoia/AP
Collegeville, Pennsylvania
6-Year Grad Rate: 80%
Average Net Price: $26,859
Average Starting Salary: $40,400
Average Midcareer Salary: $74,600
Matt Rourke/AP
Galesburg, Illinois
6-Year Grad Rate: 78.5%
Average Net Price: $22,201
Average Starting Salary: $35,000
Average Midcareer Salary: $76,000

Spokane, Washington
6-Year Grad Rate: 78.5%
Average Net Price: $22,201
Average Starting Salary: $35,000
Average Midcareer Salary: $76,000
Gregory Olsen
Meadville, Pennsylvania
6-Year Grad Rate: 80.4%
Average Net Price: $25,140
Average Starting Salary: $39,400
Average Midcareer Salary: $74,400
PRNewsFoto/Siemens Building Technologies, Inc./AP
Northfield, Minnesota
6-Year Grad Rate: 84.9%
Average Net Price: $26,276
Average Starting Salary: $39,200
Average Midcareer Salary: $77,500
PRNewsFoto/Twin Cities Public Television/AP
Boston, Massachusetts
6-Year Grad Rate: 81.3%
Average Net Price: $28,567
Average Starting Salary: $42,100
Average Midcareer Salary: $77,100

Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
6-Year Grad Rate: 76.4%
Average Net Price: $26,107
Average Starting Salary: $42,600
Average Midcareer Salary: $71,000
Matt Smith/Express-Times, via Landov
Washington, District of Columbia
6-Year Grad Rate: 77.2%
Average Net Price: $31,447
Average Starting Salary: $43,500
Average Midcareer Salary: $81,400
Jeff Watts/Courtesy of American University
Beloit, Wisconsin
6-Year Grad Rate: 75.8%
Average Net Price: $23,421
Average Starting Salary: $38,900
Average Midcareer Salary: $75,000

Appleton, Wisconsin
6-Year Grad Rate: 77.4%
Average Net Price: $26,229
Average Starting Salary: $36,400
Average Midcareer Salary: $89,500