After another lackluster week, Maura Johnston on what's ailing American Idol. Plus, VIEW OUR GALLERY of contestants who should have—and should not have—gotten to the Top 12.
Frank Micelotta / FOX,
Lilly Scott: Why She Was Worthy
Frank Micelotta / FOX
Aaron Kelly: Why He Should Have Packed His Bags
Frank Micelotta / FOX
Alex Lambert: Why He Was Worthy
Frank Micelotta / FOX
Katie Stevens: Why She Should Have Packed Her Bags
Frank Micelotta / FOX
John Park: Why He Was Worthy
Frank Micelotta / FOX
Andrew Garcia: Why He Should Have Packed His Bags
Frank Micelotta / FOX
Angela Martin: Why She Was Worthy
Michael Becker / Picture Group
Tim Urban: Why He Should Have Packed His Bags
Frank Micelotta / FOX
Michael Castro: Why He Was Worthy
Didi Benami: Why She Should Have Packed Her Bags
Frank Micelotta / FOX
Rose Flack: Why She Was Worthy
Michael Becker / Picture Group
Paige Miles: Why She Should Have Packed Her Bags (Earlier Than Wednesday Night)
