The logo for the Daily Beast's Obsessed website. It reads: 'Obsessed: What to Watch, Binge, See, & Skip'
DAILY BEAST
CrosswordNewsletters
  • Cheat Sheet
  • Obsessed
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Entertainment
  • Media
  • Innovation
  • Opinion
  • World
  • U.S. News
  • Scouted
CHEAT SHEET
    POLITICS
    • Biden World
    • Elections
    • Opinion
    • National Security
    • Congress
    • Pay Dirt
    • The New Abnormal
    • Trumpland
    MEDIA
    • Confider
    • Daytime Talk
    • Late-Night
    • Fox News
    U.S. NEWS
    • Identities
    • Crime
    • Race
    • LGBT
    • Extremism
    • Coronavirus
    WORLD
    • Russia
    • Europe
    • China
    • Middle East
    INNOVATION
    • Science
    TRAVEL
      ENTERTAINMENT
      • TV
      • Movies
      • Music
      • Comedy
      • Sports
      • Sex
      • TDB's Obsessed
      • Awards Shows
      • The Last Laugh
      CULTURE
      • Power Trip
      • Fashion
      • Books
      • Royalist
      TECH
      • Disinformation
      SCOUTED
      • Clothing
      • Technology
      • Beauty
      • Home
      • Pets
      • Kitchen
      • Fitness
      • I'm Looking For
      BEST PICKS
      • Best VPNs
      • Best Gaming PCs
      • Best Air Fryers
      COUPONS
      • Vistaprint Coupons
      • Ulta Coupons
      • Office Depot Coupons
      • Adidas Promo Codes
      • Walmart Promo Codes
      • H&M Coupons
      • Spanx Promo Codes
      • StubHub Promo Codes
      Products
      NewslettersPodcastsCrosswordsSubscription
      FOLLOW US
      GOT A TIP?

      SEARCH

      HOMEPAGE
      0

      BDS Isn't About Winning or Losing

      BDS

      Alex Kane

      Updated Jul. 13, 2017 8:54PM ET / Published Jul. 12, 2012 10:30AM ET 

      Alex Wong / Getty Images

      Jon Haber doubles down on his contention that the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) movement just keeps losing and has no momentum in his latest post for Open Zion. But Haber leaves out important context when discussing the razor-thin defeat for BDS proponents at the recent Presbyterian general assembly. And the singular focus on “winning” and “losing” obscures the bigger picture of the BDS movement’s effect on how Israel is viewed around the world.

      Haber harps on the fact that the Presbyterian vote was “the fourth time [they] have rejected proposals to divest from Israel over the last eight years.” This is true. But let’s put these defeats in context.

      The Presbyterians decided to divest in 2004, and the reaction from establishment Jewish organizations was swift. Using the tired but powerful accusation of “anti-Semitism,” they lobbied hard against divestment and defeated it at the next general assembly. By then, the BDS movement was fully on the map, and the Jewish establishment had begun to recognize the movement as something that needed to be combated.

      Fast forward to the most recent vote. The Israel Action Network, a $6 million initiative of the Jewish Federations of North America and the Jewish Council for Public Affairs (JCPA) that was created to combat BDS, sprang into action. They put all their weight into defeating the proposal to divest--and they won, but by a measly two votes. This came after a lobbying effort that included sending some Presbyterian commissioners on JCPA-sponsored trips to Israel. Moreover, liberal Zionist groups like Americans for Peace Now also weighed in against divestment, and also used the powerful “anti-Semitism” smear. So the Jewish establishment may have won, but it says something when the victory is by two votes after a campaign was waged by groups with a lot of money and political clout, things that the pro-divestment Jewish Voice for Peace lacks. But the focus on victory or defeat can be blinding. What matters equally is that BDS creates space for people to talk about Israel’s control over Palestinians and their own complicity in it. BDS movements, in whatever context, educate people on the daily indignities that Palestinians face and then give people the opportunity to do something about it. That is one of the principal strengths of the movement. Around the world, Israel’s image as a “liberal democracy” in a sea of tyranny is beginning to change. For example, an annual, worldwide BBC survey recently found that Israel was viewed negatively by half of the total respondents—putting the country in the same category as North Korea, Iran and Pakistan. While the negative image of Israel around the world isn’t the full doing of the BDS movement, it has surely contributed. BDS will continue to march ahead, and Israel lobby groups will continue to mobilize against it. And while the Jewish establishment may eke out victories, the larger narrative of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is starting to look a lot like the BDS movement’s narrative. Just take a look at this New York Times editorial published this morning. The editorial states that a recent report which concluded that Israel has the right to build settlements on occupied land draws “attention to a dispiriting anomaly: that a state founded as a democratic homeland for the Jewish people is determined to continue ruling 2.5 million Palestinians under an unequal system of laws and rights.” Sounds like apartheid to me.

      Alex Kane

      Got a tip? Send it to The Daily Beast here.

      READ THIS LIST

      DAILY BEAST
      • Cheat Sheet
      • Politics
      • Entertainment
      • Media
      • World
      • Innovation
      • U.S. News
      • Scouted
      • Travel
      • Subscription
      • Crossword
      • Newsletters
      • Podcasts
      • About
      • Contact
      • Tips
      • Jobs
      • Advertise
      • Help
      • Privacy
      • Code of Ethics & Standards
      • Diversity
      • Terms & Conditions
      • Copyright & Trademark
      • Sitemap
      • Best Picks
      • Coupons
      • Coupons:
      • Dick's Sporting Goods Coupons
      • HP Coupon Codes
      • Chewy Promo Codes
      • Nordstrom Rack Coupons
      • NordVPN Coupons
      • JCPenny Coupons
      • Nordstrom Coupons
      • Samsung Promo Coupons
      • Home Depot Coupons
      • Hotwire Promo Codes
      • eBay Coupons
      • Ashley Furniture Promo Codes
      © 2023 The Daily Beast Company LLC