CrosswordNewsletters
DAILY BEAST
ALL
  • Cheat Sheet
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Entertainment
  • Media
  • Innovation
  • Opinion
  • World
  • U.S. News
  • Scouted
  • Travel
CHEAT SHEET
    POLITICS
    • Biden World
    • Elections
    • Opinion
    • National Security
    • Congress
    • Pay Dirt
    • The New Abnormal
    • Right Richter
    • Trumpland
    MEDIA
    • Daytime Talk
    • Late-Night
    • Fox News
    U.S. NEWS
    • Identities
    • Crime
    • Race
    • LGBT
    • Extremism
    • Coronavirus
    WORLD
    • Russia
    • Europe
    • China
    • Middle East
    SCIENCE
    • Hunt for the Cure
    • Rabbit Hole
    TRAVEL
      ENTERTAINMENT
      • TV
      • Movies
      • Music
      • Comedy
      • Sports
      • Sex
      • TDBs Obsessed
      • Awards Shows
      • The Last Laugh
      HALF-FULL
        CULTURE
        • Power Trip
        • Fashion
        • Books
        • Royalist
        TECH
        • Disinformation
        SCOUTED
        • Face Masks
        • Clothing
        • Technology
        • Bedroom
        • Kitchen
        • Home
        • Fitness
        • The Case For
        • I'm Looking For
        • New Kids On the Block
        COUPONS
        • Adidas Promo Codes
        • DoorDash Promo Codes
        • H&M Coupons
        • Hotwire Promo Codes
        • Wine.com Discounts
        • Vitacost Coupons
        • Spanx Promo Codes
        • StubHub Promo Codes
        Products
        NewslettersPodcastsCrosswordsSubscription
        FOLLOW US
        GOT A TIP?

        SEARCH

        HOMEPAGE

        Kaniuk's Parting Shot at Israeli Jewish Identity

        Obituary

        Even in death, Yoram Kaniuk is challenging Israel's monopoly on Jewish identity, writes Mira Sucharov.

        Mira Sucharov

        Updated Jul. 11, 2017 10:16PM ET / Published Jun. 11, 2013 2:30PM ET 

        Salaam Shalom / Flickr

        He died on my birthday, this past weekend, a person exactly twice my age, one of the many Jews who lived out their days doing battle with their identities as citizens of Israel. Ravaged by cancer, celebrated Israeli author Yoram Kaniuk challenged convention until his final days, taking a parting shot at the religion that he never renounced, but which he challenged in the context of Jewish sovereignty.

        The author of 17 novels and seven short story collections, and the winner of Sapir Prize for Literature for his memoir 1948, an account of his experiences fighting in the War of Independence, Kaniuk was additionally thrust into public consciousness for defying convention regarding Israeli Jewish identity. In 2011, he successfully demanded that the Interior Ministry officially change his status to “no religion.” Evidently he was motivated by the fact that his wife (and thus children and grandchild) are not Jewish, and his distaste for the idea of living in what he termed a “Jewish Iran.”

        As he was dying, he shared his final wish: no burial, as Jewish tradition would dictate. Instead, he would donate his body to science, before being cremated.

        At the time of his 2011 protest, Gershom Gorenberg pointed to an irony in Kaniuk’s move to be declared “no religion,” namely that Kaniuk was “implicitly...affirm[ing] the clerical establishment's claim to represent Judaism.” “Real freedom of conscience,” Gorenberg suggested, “would require the state to stop registering religious and ethnic identity.”

        Two years after Kaniuk’s move, religion and state in Israel are very slowly being pried apart as religious pluralism is gradually coming into view.

        Still, what does it mean, amidst a legacy of pushing the Israeli state to express its mission in national, rather than in religious, terms, to abandon Jewish tradition in one’s final moments?

        All death rites have their own integral logic, their own sacred integrity, of course. But one needs only to stand at a Jewish burial, shoveling dirt to displace the air that remains around the deceased, holding up the mourners as they recite kaddish, “the one about the world that will be made new,” as Leon Wieseltier described it, and gazing outward to the Kohanim—the contemporary vestiges of the ancient priestly class who stand patiently at the edge of the cemetery—to realize how complex a statement is Kaniuk’s decision to forgo this final expression of Jewish ritual.

        As much as the Jewish state has shaped the experiencing of Jewish life according to the rhythms of the Jewish calendar, and enabled its artists, authors, poets, and songwriters to flourish under the arc of a resurrected Hebrew language, there is a clear and present tension between modern, Jewish, democratic sovereignty and the nuances of Jewish identity. To be sure, many Israelis are separately and together continuing to negotiate these questions.

        As Kaniuk has left us, the demands he has made of his state echo on, quietly framing the Aramaic of the kaddish that his loved ones may or may not be reciting for him.

        READ THIS LIST

        DAILY BEAST
        • Podcasts
        • Cheat Sheet
        • Politics
        • Crime
        • Entertainment
        • Media
        • Covid-19
        • Half Full
        • U.S. News
        • Scouted
        • Travel
        • Subscription
        • Crossword
        • Newsletters
        • Podcasts
        • About
        • Contact
        • Tips
        • Jobs
        • Advertise
        • Help
        • Privacy
        • Code of Ethics & Standards
        • Diversity
        • Terms & Conditions
        • Copyright & Trademark
        • Sitemap
        • Coupons
        © 2022 The Daily Beast Company LLC