An unsuspecting Jared Leto joined Jimmy Fallon on the Tonight Show last night for a chat and a performance with his band, 30 Seconds to Mars. Little did he know that Jimmy had other plans, including some makeover advice.

Jimmy suggested he “take the beard down a notch,” and quickly offered to help the Oscar winner out, even producing a trimmer and barber’s apron. After making some Jesus jokes at his own expense, Leto agreed to the trim job, which turned out to be only a little awkward.